Walmart V Samara

In: Business and Management

Submitted By hddpower
Words 1637
Pages 7
Review and History of Supreme Court Case titled
Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Samara Brothers, Inc.

Lee Dupree

Prof. Michael Hanners

LEG 565
Commercial Law


Before the Case
Ultimately, the goal of trade dress protection has always been to prevent other manufacturers from making one product look like another, therefore deceiving unaware consumers into purchasing goods from the wrong manufacturer. By the end of the 1990s, courts also began to protect product shapes and packaging. The broad label of unfair competition supplied product packaging and shapes with legal protection, known as trade dress. Trade dress was meant to make it easier for consumers to differentiate products by their dress and associate a product and its manufacturer with the dress as well. By default, this protection extended to protect the producer’s investment in the advertising and promotion of the product, and also allowed producers to sue on behalf of consumers who would have a difficult time bringing suit based on their confusion. Samara Brothers, Inc. designs and produces clothing for children and the most profitable part of its business was spring and summer one piece outfits that display items such as hearts or flowers. In 1995, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. contacted one of its suppliers, Judy-Phillipine, Inc. and contracted them to produce an entire line of children’s clothing patterned after photographs of Samara clothes. (It should be noted that Judy-Phillipe, Inc. supplied the clothing line to K-Mart, Caldor, Hills, and Goody’s also.) In 1996, a J.C. Penny consumer informed Samara that its exact designs were being sold by Walt-Mart at lower prices than J.C. Penny was contracted to offer; this acted as Samara’s discovery that Wal-Mart was selling their designs. Samara sent cease-and-desist letters and then sued Wal-Mart, Judy-Phillipine, K-Mart, Caldor, Hills, and…...

Similar Documents


...them today and for this they make calls, looks for the advertisements and promotions and sales offers etc. References Delzell, D (2007). From RetailWire: Wal-Mart Classifies Customers for     Growth . News and Views, , 237-238. Retrieved from http://www.s Lakshman, N (2009). Why Wal-Mart's First India Store Isn't a Wal-Mart Read more: Retrieved from,8599,1898823,00.html Spulber, D (2007). Global Competitive Strategy. Global Competitive Strategy, 237-238. Retrieved from  ks?id=srtvAKRDfYoC&pg=PA237&dq=Walmart+competitive+stratgey&cd=1#v=onepage&q=&f=false...

Words: 682 - Pages: 3

Walmart [4] When a Wal-Mart is built it usually destroys the small businesses in that area over time, it has not slowed them down one bit. In a paper published in the Farm Foundation 1997, Kenneth Stone, Professor of Economics at Iowa State University, found that some small town communities can lose almost half of their retail trade within 10 years of a Wal-Mart opening a store. [5] This causes most of the Mom and Pop’s in the area to be forced out of business and also reduces the amount of jobs available in the community. They have been accused of predatory pricing, investigated by the FCC for monopolistic practices, and undermining competition in Germany. The big box giant was taken to court in 1995 in a case of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. American Drugs, Inc. The pharmaceutical retailer accused Wal-Mart of selling items at too low a cost for the purpose on injuring competitors and destroying competition. Wal-Mart won the case in Arkansas when the Supreme Court ruled in their favor stating that it’s pricing, including the use of lose leaders, was not predatory pricing.[6] There were two more cases in the state of Oklahoma about predatory pricing but before a ruling was made Wal-Mart settled out of court. Mexico’s antitrust agency the FCC, the Federal Competition Commission, investigated them in 2003 for monopolistic practices. They were provoked by charges that the retailer pressured suppliers to sell goods below cost or at prices significantly less than those available to......

Words: 5612 - Pages: 23

Walmart vs Samara Bros

...Introduction Samara Brothers, Inc. designs and manufactures a line of children's clothing. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., contracted with a supplier, Judy-Philippine, Inc. (JPI), to manufacture outfits based on photographs of Samara garments and to be offered under Wal-Mart's house label, "Small Steps." When JPI manufactured the clothes, it copied sixteen of Samara's garments with some small modifications to produce the line of clothes required under its contract with Wal-Mart. After discovering that Wal-Mart and other retailers were selling the so-called knockoffs, Samara brought an action for infringement of unregistered trade dress under section 43(a) of the Trademark Act of 1946. The jury found for Samara and awarded the company more than $1 million in damages. Wal-Mart then renewed a motion for judgment as a matter of law, claiming that there was insufficient evidence to support a conclusion that Samara's clothing designs could be legally protected as distinctive trade dress for purposes of section 43(a). The District Court denied the motion and awarded Samara relief. The Court of Appeals affirmed the denial of the motion and concluded that "copyrights depicting familiar objects, such as the hearts, daisies, and strawberries in Samara's copyrights are entitled to very narrow protection. It is only the virtually identical copying...which will result in a successful claim of infringement of familiar objects." 2-)Rule of Law/Rationale The legal framework used to analyze whether......

Words: 2300 - Pages: 10


...of Wal-Mart’s actions to better coordinate employee wages paid to its employees in the U.S. and abroad, and the corporation's staunch anti-union views and actions, for example closing a Wal-Mart store in Quebec after its employees unionized (Woodlands 2012). Frazeer’s article was helpful in that it offered insight into the situation from the perspective of the workers. The article presented the testimonies of workers both foreign and domestic reflecting upon the attitudes and in some instances the realities of what working for Wal-Mart is really like, even for veteran workers. The article discussed the experience of Cynthia Murray, a fitting room associate for Walmart in Maryland who spoke-out against the low-wages and expressed her discontent that she has no healthcare coverage and was quoted as asking Walmart to “stop paying poverty wages and to give [them] benefits.” John R. Schermerhorn’s “Organizational Behavior” served to bring all the pieces together. The numerous concepts covered from ‘organizational culture’, ‘social capital’, ‘soft assets’, ‘job satisfaction’ and a plethora of others were defined within this textbook. The textbook further served to instruct us on how to determine a plan-of-action to address the various issues we have identified as posing barriers to creating a constructive organizational culture within the Wal-Mart organization. Analysis Upon review of the situation between Wal-Mart, the organization, and their rank-and-file employees,......

Words: 4735 - Pages: 19


...and Success John A. Parnell, University of North Carolina-Pembroke Donald L. Lester, Middle Tennessee State University No class of retailer has influenced the business landscape in recent years more than the big box, and no big boxer is more prominent than WalMart. Big boxers like Wal-Mart not only apply pressure to suppliers and alter the mix of shopping alternatives for consumers, but they also greatly influence the competitive behavior of traditional retailers. The academic and business press has chronicled the wide-ranging effects of the mega-retailer over the past two decades (McCune, 1994; McGee and Peterson, 2000; Stone, 1993). Although there is growing evidence that Wal-Mart's hold on retail may be slipping, it remains a competitive nightmare for many of its competitors, particularly small rivals in local markets (McWiltiams, 2()07a. 2007b). A number of authors (e.g.. McGee and Peterson, 2000; Edid, 2005; Spector, 2005) have suggested or inferred competitive responses for smaller retailers when a big box like Wal-Mart comes to town. This paper builds on such work by providing a more comprehensive and theorybased analysis of strategic alternatives available to retailers specifically facing a threat from WalMart. Toward that end, the remainder of the paper begins with an overview of the big box phenomenon and a framework for understanding how the big box influences the strategic landscape. Three theory-based potential strategic responses are evaluated, followed by......

Words: 8406 - Pages: 34


...Walmart Slide1 Welcome to our presentation, our topic is Walmart, I will present the pro arguments for Walmart and Cherrif will present the arguments against Walmart. Slide 2 First of all I want to say some basic facts about walmart. Sam Walton created walmart in the year 1962 and he opened the first walmart in the same year in 1962 in Arkansas. Today we can say walmart has more than 9000 stores worldwide and its spread over 15 countries. Think about it for a second Sam Walton created walmart only 50 years ago and the company has over 2 million employees. That is amazing. Slide 3 Now you can see a quote from Sam Walton about Walmart. Slide reading. That is everything what expect from a store for customers. Slide 4 Some more facts: it is the worlds lagest public corporation by revenue. Furthermore the largest private employer in the world. A really important part in walmart is the grocery part, it is the largest grocery seller in the US and it is friendly to children you can see it in the fact that walmart is the largest toy seller in the us. Slide 5 Walmart has not only toys or a big grocery part, walmart brings low prices and the conveniece of shopping at one place, where you can find everything. You dont have to go to different stores to buy, walmart has everything what you need. You save a lot of time to go to walmart and buy there. Plus the walmart prices are between 15% and 22% less expenisive than the market price/ the other stores. And it is open...

Words: 689 - Pages: 3


...Cost Leadership and Differentiation Strategies @Walmart Submitted by: Samrat Basu INDEX PAGE Walmart Origin Page-3 Walmart Mission/Vision Page-4 Corporate Culture@ Walmart Page-4 Competitive Position of Walmart Page 5-6 Strategies @ Walmart Page 6-9 Private Label and Store Layout Page 9-11 Conclusion Page-11 Appendix Page 12 References and Bibliography Page 13-14 Wal-Mart- Origin Wal-Mart was the product of Sam Walton, a businessman from Arkansas. In the late 1940s, in USA, a retailer who was successful in obtaining a sufficient discount for his products from the whole-seller, used to sell the products at full price to the customers and thus enjoyed a substantial amount of profit. Sam Walton during that time was working as a retailer at a J.C. Penney store in Des Moines, Iowa.(Walton & Huey, 1993) Incidentally while working there, he was introduced to Butler Brothers, a big retailer who had chains of variety stores known as Ben Franklin and Sam was......

Words: 4491 - Pages: 18


...Christian Baca Boycott Wal-mart Introduction I. I will start off with wal-marts slogan. II. To persuade. III. After listening to my speech my audience will be more likely to shop elsewhere IV. We need to stop supporting unfair companies like wal-mart. V. Each person in the class needs to consider shopping at other stores. VI. Today I will talk to you about several negative aspects tied to Wal-Mart such as low wages, tough working conditions, female discrimination and the undermining of labor laws, how people can come together and push for a better corporation, and what you can do today to start. Body I. Wal-mart is the largest retailer and private employer in the United States but still pays low wages and discriminates against women. A. With record sales of 300 billion a year the company hasn’t risen its wages sticking to minimum wage and also making it hard for women to climb up the ladder to leadership positions.(Lichtenstein,2006) 1. Wal-mart underpays and under staffs sometimes even forcing employees to work through their breaks and lunches.(Featherstone,2004) B. You may think wal-mart moving in to your town means lower prices for you but it doesn’t come for free. 1. If a Wal-Mart store opens in a community it creates competition meaning every other store around that wal-mart needs to find ways to compete whether it means lowering wages or laying off employees it could be you next. ......

Words: 599 - Pages: 3


...them in the US. Although the company was using products that were made in the U.S. Wal-Mart was rapidly growing overseas. In 1991 they had only one store in Mexico. By 1998 they had over 600 stores overseas, which accounted for about 5 percent of their growth in sales and profits. Wal-Mart was very successful in the United States but in order for them to survive and grow they had to begin building stores overseas (Govindarajan & Gupta, 2002). Wal-Mart also had so many stores in the United States that their only other option to continue to grow was to move into other countries. Wal-Mart has been able to grow into the number one retailer in the United States. According to Bloomberg, the current Chief Executive Officer (CEO) at Walmart is Michael Terry Duke. Mr. Duke has been the CEO at Wal-Mart Stores Inc. since 2006 (2011). And Bloomberg also reports that Charles M. Holley Jr. is the current Chief Financial Officer of Wal-Mart and has held that position since late 2010. Mr. Holley’s education background consists of a MBA from the University of Houston. His financial experience is quite extensive and he has been working within the Wal-Mart Stores Inc. finance scene since 1999. Before that he started working for Wal-Mart he was with Ernst & Young for over ten years (2011). After examining Mr. Holley’s experience, I believe that he is well qualified for the position that he currently holds. He has over a decade of experience within Wal-Mart itself dealing......

Words: 1380 - Pages: 6

Walmart Stores Inc. vs. Samara Brothers Inc,

...Walmart Stores, Inc. vs. Samara Brothers, Inc. : Commercial Law 1. Summarize the facts associated with Walmart Stores, Inc. v. Samara Brothers, Inc. Samara is a manufacturer of children's clothing. The core of Samara's business is its line of spring/summer seersucker children's garments. Wal-Mart is a national chain of retail stores which sells a variety of items, including children's clothes. In 1995, Wal-Mart contracted with Judy-Philippine, Inc. (“JPI”) to have JPI manufacture for Wal-Mart a large quantity of children's seersucker garments to be offered for sale under Wal-Mart's house label, “Small Steps,” in the 1996 spring/summer season. The samples on which the Wal-Mart buyers' orders of JPI garments were based were actually Samara garments.   In other words, the Wal-Mart paperwork preparatory for placing an order bears photographs of the garments being ordered, and in many of those photographs the name “Samara” is readily discernible on the hangtags and/or neck labels of the garments. When JPI manufactured the clothes, it copied sixteen of Samara's garments with some small modifications to produce the line of clothes required under its contract with Wal-Mart. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. then sold these items in its stores under the “Small Steps” label. Samara holds copyright registrations on thirteen of the sixteen garments copied.   In early June 1996, a buyer at J.C. Penney, one of a number of stores......

Words: 2260 - Pages: 10


... Executive Summary Wal-Mart Stores Inc. is the largest retail company in the United States and has been ranked number one on the Fortune 500 Index by Fortune Magazine. Wal-Mart has four parts to their corporate strategy. 1. Dominance in the Retail Market 2. Expansion in the U.S. and International Markets 3. Creation of Positive Brand and Company Recognition 4. Branch Out into New Sectors of Retail Wal-Mart’s public affairs strategy must work to make implementation of these policy goals happen. Its public affairs strategy enables the company to move into other sectors of the marketplace and expand into foreign countries. The public affairs strategy also involves gaining access to politicians who can help Wal-Mart achieve its goals. WalMart has a very active Political Action Committee that gives almost a quarter million dollars annually. While Wal-Mart’s public affairs strategy works well with its corporate strategy. W e feel that there are a few recommendations which could make the company work better. Recently, Wal-Mart has been criticized for their opposition to allowing their employees to be unionized. Wal-Mart needs to clarify their reasons for their opposition to unionization. The public affairs strategy must also address the negative feelings harbored by some groups who feel that Wal-Mart is encroaching into far too many other sectors retail than it should. These concerns must be addressed if Wal-Mart is to enjoy continued success in creating positive......

Words: 10186 - Pages: 41


...| Walmart | | | | | Danielle S Holley | 11/28/2011 | | Firms choose from different business-level strategies in order to proposer in today’s markets. One of these being the Cost Leadership Strategy, an integrated set of actions taken to produce goods or services with features that are acceptable to customers at the lowest cost, in comparison to their competitors. Firms that chose to use this strategy must sell standardized goods and services which have to also include competitive levels of differentiation to the market’s regular customers. Cost leaders have to examine all support activities to find extra resources in order to cut production costs allowing them to maintain low costs for their customers. In any industry fixed and variable costs can cause companies to go out of business. Cost Leadership Strategy can put a strain on companies because they have to keep developing new technology that can support low cost goods and services (with differentiation) as well as low production costs to satisfy the needs of customers in the market place. Using this strategy effectively can earn firms above-average returns in spite of rivals in the industry. Having the low-cost position in an industry is valuable way to deal with competitors. The cost leader’s strategic position causes competitors to think twice before they compete on the basics of price and technology against the potential outcomes of such competition (Hitt). Walmart is known for its......

Words: 5753 - Pages: 24


...military service, Sam Walton opened a five-and dime store in 1945 in Bentonville, Arkansas (Wal-Mart, 2016). Sam was successful and inspired in his first venture and was driven to focus on consumers and providing value, Sam opened his first Wal-Mart store in 1962 in Rogers, Arkansas. By 1967, 24 Wal-Mart stores had opened. Sam’s vision was to “save people money so they could live better”, his core value was that of respect, for customers, employees and suppliers (Ghazzawi, Palladini & Martinelli-Lee, 2014) and this continues to be the mission and values of Walmart today. Since the opening of the first store in 1962, Wal-Mart has grown to 11,500 stores, operating in all fifty states, as well as 28 countries, under 72 banners and e-commerce, and employees 2.2 million people and weekly services 260 million customers and members. The Wal-Mart, Incorporated consists of four operating divisions Wal-Mart U.S., Walmart International. Sam’s Club and Global e-Commerce (Wal-Mart, 2016). Analysis of Management Functions: Planning. Based on what you have learned through your research, how would you characterize conditions in the planning environment? What types of problems does the organization face (e.g., structured, unstructured), and to what extent should the organizations decisions be programmed or nonprogrammed? How would you characterize the level certainty, uncertainty, and risk the organization faces? Organizing. How is the organization organized? Would you......

Words: 4659 - Pages: 19

Mcdonalds V Walmart

...Assignment #3 Rayna Williams Dr. S. L. Terrell Managerial Economics and Globalization – ECO 550 November 20, 2011 1. Some games of strategy are cooperative. One example is deciding which side of the road to drive on. It doesn’t matter which side it is as long as everyone chooses the same side. Otherwise, everyone may get hurt. Driver 2 Left Right Driver 1 Left 0, 0 -1000 -1000 Right -1000, -1000 0, 0 a. Does either player have a dominant strategy? Explain. Driver 2’s strategy: If diver 1 turns left, driver 2 has two choices: Left or right. Driver 2 would turn left as payoff (0) is higher there than negative payoff in Right. Then if diver 1 turns right, driver 2 has two choices: Left or right and he also would turn to right due to higher (0) payoff. As a result, driver 2 does not have a dominant strategy because he moves in a same direction of Driver 1 does and the dominant strategy is regardless of what any other players do, the strategy earns a player a larger payoff than any other. Driver 1’s strategy: If diver 2 turns left, driver 1 has two choices: Left or right and driver 1 would turn to left due to higher payoff (0). Then if diver 2 turns right, driver 1 has two choices where he would turn to right as the payoff is higher (0) than......

Words: 571 - Pages: 3


...New York, NY: Doubleday Publishing. Brady, D., & Zellner, W. (2003, October 6). Is Wal-Mart to powerful? Business Week. Retrieved from b3852001_mz001.htm Brunn, S.D. (2006). Wal-Mart world: The world’s biggest corporation in the global economy. New York, NY: Routledge. Retrieved from books?id=Lt6Zr_C6FooC&pg=PA173&dq=wal+marts+buy+american+campaign&hl=en&ei=E1UhTP-jCM39nQevodl1&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result &resnum=4&ved=0CDwQ6AEwAw#v=onepage&q&f=false Carrol, A. B., & Buchholtz, A. K. (2006). Business and society, ethics and stakeholder management. Mason, OH: South-Western Publishing. Frank, D. (1999). Buy American: The untold story of economic nationalism. Boston, MA: Beacon Press. Retrieved from ?id= MyIoy7F9uEoC&pg=PA200&dq=wal+marts+buy+american+campaign&hl=en&ei=E1UhTP-jCM39nQevodl1&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum =1&ved=0CC4Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false Friedman, M. (1970, September 13). The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits. The New York Times. Retrieved from studentgroups/libertarians/issues/friedman-soc-resp-business.html doi: 10.1007/978-3-540-70818-6_14 Gerstein, J. (2005, October 5). Wal-Mart’s charity is self-serving. The New York Sun. Retrieved from serving-a-philanthropy/21016/ Issues/environment. (n.d.)...

Words: 3625 - Pages: 15