In: People

Submitted By foye2
Words 1725
Pages 7
Modern Democracy: An Online Chaos? In Cass Sunstein’s book 2.0, he discusses advances in modern technologies and communications and the affect each have on our democratic society. Sunstein makes reasonable arguments supporting both the positive influences on our nation of these steps forward as well as the detrimental issues they have caused. Though Sunstein does recognize that the modern media is a blessing for society as a whole, he makes the argument that one must be careful with it if the United States wishes to maintain a fair democratic form of government. Cass Sunstein is not wrong to be concerned with the power and changes that the advances in technology, especially the Internet, have caused. However, Sunstein has an overly radical view of what must be done, an unrealistic view of the true good, and how that good outweighs the cons brought by this new digital world. The discussion begins with a firm statement of Sunstein’s concerns about the negative affects of the Internet on the liberal democracy intended by America’s Founding Fathers. His principle concerns are the momentous increase in the availability of personalized filtering and the decrease in general-interest intermediaries such as national newspapers and news networks. Both of these concerns are plausible ones, for they truly have changed the way democracy functions and the way that ideas flow in the United States. Filtering today is different than it used to be in the past. Before the Internet and the miraculous capabilities that it introduced, filtering was mostly done by the producers of mass media. The editors decided what information to include or exclude before sharing it with the country. As such, a fair balance between different viewpoints (such as those of the liberal and those of the more conservative) was more likely to be displayed. However, now that…...

Similar Documents


... Nichie, Elizabeth. Mary Shelley: Author of Frankenstein. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1953. Robert M. M. Veatch. The Basics of Bioethics. Prentice Hall, 1999. Small, Christopher. Mary Shelley's Frankenstein. University of Pittsburgh Press, 1973. "Shelley Biography." Mary Shelley Biography. N.p., n.d. Web. 14 Jan. 2013. Shelley, Mary Wollstonecraft. Frankenstein or, The Modern Prometheus. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1984. Shelley, Mary. Frankenstein, introduction by Diane Johnson. Bantam Books, 1991. Spark, Muriel. Mary Shelley. New York: E. P. Dutton, 1987. Sunstein, Emily W. Mary Shelley: Romance and Reality. Boston: Little Brown & Company, 1989. Steven Earl Forry. Hideous Progenies: Dramatizations of Frankenstein from Mary Shelley to the Present. University of Pennsylvania Press. 1990. Sunstein, Emily W. Mary Shelley: Romance and Reality. Little, Brown, and Co., 1989. Terry O'Neill. Biomedical Ethics. Greenhaven Press, 1998. Grade 8 and up. The Mary Shelley Reader: Containing Frankenstein, Mathilda, Tales and Stories, Essays and Reviews, and Letters by Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley. Betty T. Bennett and Charles E. Robinson, eds. Oxford University Press, 1990. Timothy Marshall. Murdering to Dissect: Graverobbing, Frankenstein, and the Anatomy Literature. St. Martin's Press, Inc., 1996. Vasbinder, Samuel Holmes. Scientific Attitudes in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein. Ann Arbor, MI: UMI Research Press, 1984....

Words: 674 - Pages: 3

Individuality and the Internet

...internet and become distracted by mundane and useless information. It seems that the second a webpage is opened the user is bombarded by pictures of celebrities, the newest styles in fashion, the newest fads in religion and health, and how to best raise one’s child. Areas of life that were previously a matter of individual decision-making are now becoming uniform topics that are discussed throughout the web. The more these ideas are advertised, the more they are imitated. And thus, the less originality there is. As imitation increases the closer society becomes to uniformity. Cass Sunstein addresses the idea of change inspired by the internet in Democracy and the Internet, “Cascade effects are common on the internet… It is obvious that many social groups, both large and small, seem to move both rapidly and dramatically in the direction of one or another set of beliefs or actions,” (Sunstein,103) . Sunstein touches on an important negative factor of the internet that supports the conclusion that the internet spreads information rapidly creating groups of individuals that have the same knowledge and beliefs. Conceptions of beauty is one example of an area of life that would normally be confined to the individuality of personal thought, but is now formed by the internet. Beauty is constantly in the limelight on the internet. Perceptions of what constitutes beauty are shown on the internet at all times. The internet and the laziness that it inspires in our use of it have......

Words: 2239 - Pages: 9

Mass Media Messages and Effects

...give out whatever information that they want , even without first checking the facts to make sure that they are correct. The worry is that such insularity will promote extremism and the reinforcement of ill-founded opinions, while also preventing citizens of a democracy from recognizing their shared interests and experiences (Sunstein,2008) ( ) Yes, social networking is fun but there are a lot of ethical concerns that has developed and we must all be careful when using the social networks. In modern society, we have given up a lot of our privacy and civil rights because we are a society that is based on technology and the convenience that it brings to our daily lives. As new technology and more social media sites are created, we will face more unethical practices in social networks. We all enjoy the social networks, but at what price. References Bakardjieva, M. and Gaden, G., 2011, “Web 2.0 Technologies of the Self,” Philosophy of Technology. Retrieved from Sunstein, C., 2008, “Democracy and the Internet,” in Information Technology and Moral Philosophy. Retrieved from

Words: 512 - Pages: 3

Nytimes Article

...trial at the Essex job center — one that is part of a much larger social experiment underway in Britain. A small band of psychologists and economists is quietly working to transform the nation’s policy making. Inspired by behavioral science, the group fans out across the country to job centers, schools and local government offices and tweaks bureaucratic processes to better suit human nature. The goal is to see if small interventions that don’t cost much can change behavior in large ways that serve both individuals and society. It is an American idea, refined in American universities and popularized in 2008 with the best seller “Nudge,” by Richard H. Thaler and Cass R. Sunstein. Professor Thaler, a contributor to the Economic View column in Sunday Business, is an economist at the University of Chicago, and Mr. Sunstein was a senior regulatory official in the Obama administration, where he applied behavioral findings to a range of regulatory policies, but didn’t have the mandate or resources to run experiments. But it is in Britain that such experiments have taken root. Prime Minister David Cameron has embraced the idea of testing the power of behavioral change to devise effective policies, seeing it not just as a way to help people make better decisions, but also to help government do more for less. In 2010, Mr. Cameron set up the Behavioral Insights Team — or nudge unit, as it’s often called. Three years later, the team has doubled in size and is about to announce a......

Words: 600 - Pages: 3

Libertarian Paternalim

...defined by Richard Thaler and Cass Sunstein, is an act that attempts to influence the choices of others in such a way that those others will be better off, and that these others would agree that they are better off. A less coercive form of paternalism is known as libertarian paternalism. Libertarian paternalism is when policies are designed to influence people to make certain choices without limiting their liberty or options. The means by which people are to be influenced to make these decisions are known as nudges. Nudges are factors in a choice that will change individuals’ behaviors in a way that the person nudging has anticipated. Thaler and Sunstein are advocates of nudges and see libertarian paternalism as a nice medium between outright coercion and complete free choice. They make the claim that libertarian paternalism can help anticipate and correct certain instances in which a person does not make decisions in their best interests. Daniel Hausman and Brynn Welch of the University of Wisconsin, Madison, contend that the definition of paternalism put forth by Thaler and Sunstein is wrong and that nudges are, in fact, paternalistic. I will first outline the claims of Thaler and Sunstein and then the criticism of the policies as put forth by Hausman and Welch. Finally, I will argue that libertarian paternalism is essentially the same concept as the paternalism defined by Hausman and Welch. As already stated, according to Thaler and Sunstein, paternalism is an act that......

Words: 1854 - Pages: 8


...SACHS.DOCX (DO NOT DELETE) 8/1/2011 2:07 PM RESCUING THE STRONG PRECAUTIONARY PRINCIPLE FROM ITS CRITICS Noah M. Sachs* The Strong Precautionary Principle, an approach to risk regulation that shifts the burden of proof on safety, can provide a valuable framework for preventing harm to human health and the environment. Cass Sunstein and other scholars, however, have consistently criticized the Principle, rejecting it as paralyzing, inflexible, and extreme. In this reassessment of the Strong Precautionary Principle, I highlight the significant benefits of the Principle for risk decision making, with the aim of rescuing the Principle from its dismissive critics. The Principle sends a clear message that firms must research the health and environmental risks of their products, before harm occurs. It does not call for the elimination of all risk, nor does it ignore tradeoffs, as Sunstein has alleged. Rather, through burden shifting, the Principle legitimately requires risk creators to research and justify the risks they impose on society. By exploring where the Principle already operates successfully in U.S. law—examples often overlooked by the critics—I highlight the Principle’s flexibility and utility in regulatory law. This Article uses chemical regulation as a case study in how the Principle can guide Congress in an ongoing controversy. Congress is considering a major overhaul of the flawed Toxic Substances Control Act of 1976 (TSCA), and this change could be one of the most......

Words: 29197 - Pages: 117

Nudging Students with Information

...Introduction At university students experience a lot of freedom as the majority of classes is facultative. This means students have a choice to attend the class or not. But people, and thus students as well, sometimes fail to do a good job at making choices because of self-control problems (Thaler and Sunstein, 2003). For example; they invest too little effort in their education because they value present consumption more than future consumption, have time- inconsistent preferences or underestimate the return on education (Gneezy et al., 2011). As some students tend to procrastinate studying and skip classes, some kind of paternalism might be helpful to reduce this behavior. (Libertarian) paternalism is a way to steer people’s choices in directions that will promote their welfare, but at the same time preserving freedom of choice (Thaler and Sunstein, 2003). This can be done by creating a choice architecture which is an environment consisting of specific features which influences the choice of people in some direction (Thaler et al., 2010). These features could be defaults, expecting error, mappings, feedback, structuring complex choices and creating incentives (Thaler and Sunstein, 2003). Here the focus will lie on a constructed choice architecture by means of information provision to students through reminders and on social norms. Firstly, I will discuss a randomized field experiment on nudging with information by Calzolari and Nardotto (2012) in which they find that......

Words: 3657 - Pages: 15

The Ethics of Fieldwork

...Research. In 1979, the Commission published what’s commonly called “the Belmont Report,” which identifies three basic principles relevant to the ethics of research involving human subjects: respect for persons, beneficence, and justice” (Sunstein and Chiseri-Strater 121-122). All informants should be volunteers in any research projects. They also have to have enough information about the research and then to decide if they would like to be a part of this research. First of all, if we decided to take an interview for our research study, we have to ask our informant to sign formal permission or at least an informed consent form. For example, before I took an interview with Dasha, she gave permission to me to interview her for my English class research paper. I explained the project to Dasha, and she even did not ask me to read the final draft with all information she provided. The only thing Dasha asked me to use a pseudonym instead of her real name. It would not be ethical if I did not protect the anonymity of my informant. To be a good researcher we have to show a respect for person. “Researchers should protect informants against risk from harm and also from the loss of any benefit that might be gained from research” (Sunstein and Chiseri-Strater 122). For instance, last semester I wrote a great essay about TJ Maxx. The paper was so good, that one of my friend said that I could ask for discount from this store because I my essay was an amazing......

Words: 479 - Pages: 2

Endocrine Disruptors

...inaction due to scientific uncertainty. The vagueness of the principle doesn’t specify what is considered a proper threshold of “risk” so in reality the use of the principle could be looked at as theory because its considered untested. A second criticism of the precautionary principle is the view that it holds back innovation. A technology which brings advantages may be banned by the precautionary principle because of its potential for negative impacts, leaving the positive benefits unrealized. (SUNSTEIN, 2002-2003) Bibliography Dictionary, C. E. (2016, January 31). Collins English Dictionary - Complete & Unabridged 10th Edition. Retrieved from Endocrine Disruptors . (2016, January 31). Retrieved from National Institute of Enviromental Health Sciences: Pesticides. (2016, January 31). Retrieved from SUNSTEIN, C. R. (2002-2003). The Paralyzing Principle . Regulation , 1-6....

Words: 530 - Pages: 3

Philosophy (Sunstein and Nussbaum 309). The aim of the capability theory is to put forward political solutions that will foster coexistence and cooperation among the species. The author notes that there exist positive and negative, ability and functioning distinctions that be defined clearly. Below are the human basis capability approaches that are applied in mapping out political principles and policies that are aimed at helping in the protection of nonhuman species. They include life, bodily health, bodily integrity, senses, imaginations and thought, emotions, political reasons affiliation, other species, play, and control over the environment (Sunstein and Nussbaum 313). The list was termed as complete regarding coverage but open for further evaluations. Simply stated, the implication is a call for the nation to take the responsibility of protecting the nonhuman species. This is done through the inclusion of specific clauses in the country laws and as well in the constitution. About using the animals in the research practices, it is important to ensure that they are used responsibly and ensure that the sufferings inflicted are at least a minimum. The researchers should focus on the treatment procedures in case the animal contract any disease during an experiment, avoid frivolous damages and development of methods that reduce the direct interactions with the animals. Animals have a right to a dignified existence in order not just to survive, but as well to flourish (Sunstein and......

Words: 1463 - Pages: 6


...conventional wisdom to win. (Thaler & Sunstein, 2003). Lewis’s book points out the extraordinary success of Beane’s baseball team despite the fact that the payroll for the team is consistently in the bottom two or three spots in the league. (Thaler & Sunstein, 2003) Thaler and Sunstein make the case that “the limits on human rationality and efficiency of labor markets” make for blunders and confusion with those who run baseball teams and ultimately correlates to similar blunders and confusions in many other fields. (Thaler & Sunstein, 2003) Lewis describes how Beane is heavily recruited primarily because of his own body and face and not his actual ability to play baseball. “Scouts never looked at his statistics because according to the scouts, he had it all” (Thaler & Sunstein, 2003, para. 6) The authors goes on to say, that even though Beane was selected in the first round of the draft, he had one big problem and that was that he did not play baseball very well. (Thaler & Sunstein, 2003, para. 5) Baseball scouts saw his body, face and raw talent and this made them believe he was destined to succeed. Unfortunately, after several years in major league baseball his performance was miserably bad. (Thaler & Sunstein, 2003) The article goes on to say, that eventually Beane decides to become an advanced baseball scout and that he is a much better baseball analyst than baseball player.(Thaler & Sunstein, 2003, para. 8) He becomes very......

Words: 845 - Pages: 4

Nudge: Cognitive Manipulation and Behavioral Science

...toward making optimal decisions. The second half of Nudge illustrates how the same concepts and principles can be used, are being used, should be used, and how to better utilize them to nudge public policy. Thaler and Sunstein (2009, p. 6) detail two terms that must be explained in order to understand the points made throughout the book. The first, ‘nudge’ is “any aspect of the choice architecture that alters people’s behavior in a predictable way without forbidding any options or significantly changing their economic incentives.” They go on to say “To count as a mere nudge, the intervention must be easy and cheap to avoid. Nudges are not mandates.” The second term used throughout Nudge is ‘choice architect’ (Thaler & Sunstein, 2009, p. 3), defined by the authors as someone that “has the responsibility for organizing the context in which people make decisions.” Choice architects arrange choices for other people and nudge others toward making decisions that will be at the optimum benefit. A choice architect will favor one option over another and take necessary measures to put a chooser on a particular path while keeping other choices available and not making other choices more difficult to make. Arranging these choices can influence the way people think. Thaler and Sunstein describe situations where a choice architect may choose to nudge people towards one choice over another for the benefit of that person. They have dubbed this type of philosophy as ‘libertarian paternalism’.......

Words: 5498 - Pages: 22

Capital Punishment

...murder. In a recent paper, written by Cass Sunstein, he states, “"If each execution is saving many lives," they conclude, "the harms of capital punishment would have to be very great to justify its abolition, far greater than most critics have heretofore alleged."” He argues that if the death penalty effectively deters murders then it not only is “morally licit but morally required”. His statement suggests a utilitarian approach would make sense to sentence a convicted murderer to death to help save the lives of others. To reflect further on morality, which is the right and wrong principles our societies, I would suggest that a person should be awarded for good deeds but also punished for wrong doings to others. I believe that it is important to punish individuals in an effort to not only teach the ones who have committed the wrong doing but also those who may be influenced by the punishment of the wrong doer. To say that life in prison is a justifiable punishment for someone who has taken a life or raped a child is simply just slapping criminals on the wrist. Most prisoners today are able to live in prisons that allow for visitor sessions, air-conditioned cells, opportunity for recreation time, and are usually served three free meals a day. This type of punishment hardly seems fair to the victims of these crimes or morally justifiable because the criminals are not forced to learn a lesson from this punishment. I agree with Mr. Sunstein that all governments should be morally......

Words: 1657 - Pages: 7


...concerns were marginalized (Auerbach, M 2009). In 1944, FDR also introduced the notion of a “Secound Bill of Rights,” which lent a philisophical ideal to his proposed policies. Stemming from his concept of the “four freedoms” freedom of speech, religion, fear and want, the Secound Bill of Rights was designed to emphasize the latter of these freedoms by working to ensure that every individual had a right to make as comfortable a living as possible (Sunstein, 2006). One of the longest-lasting aspects of Roosevelts’s “welfare state” (a system in which the governement assumes responsibility over the health, education, employment and social security of the people) was that of Social Security, which is used to help the handicapped and elderly remain free from want. Thirty years after the Roosevelt administration, the leadership team of President Lyndon Johnson took charge to buld upon the legacy of FDR (Auerbach, M. 2009). Johnson managed to invest $6 billion into Medicare and another $1.3 billion into education reform appropriation (Sunstein, 2006). Johnson, addressing both the U.S. Capital chambers, declared “war on poverty,” promting more people to get involved and the federal government to get more active in servicing the people’s needs (“The New Welfare State”, 1965). In addition to his Medicare and educations measures, Johnson’s “war on poverty” included the introduction of the Head Start program, work study initiatives, food stamps, and health care insurence......

Words: 1989 - Pages: 8

Consumer Behavior

...considering the new product but they are not trying it out on a small scale. One way to overcome this is by sending them a free sample or by giving them a gift for trying out the product. AOL became a great success by mailing millions of free trial offers (100 free hours on the Internet) to the public. ************************************Behavioral Economics (Optional Topic--will not be on exam unless I explicitly indicate that you are responsible for it)*************************************************** There is a new area of economics known as behavioral economics that attempts to understand how people make decisions.  One book that is especially fascinating is Nudge:  Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth, and Happiness by Thaler and Sunstein.  The authors discuss how government can use  "choice architecture" to gently push (i.e., nudge) people to making the right choices.  The traditional belief of economists that we are all "rational man" and behave in a rational way that maximizes self interest is simply not true. Another book that you will find interesting is Predictably Irrational by Dan Ariely.  As you will see, marketers can learn a great deal about consumer motivation by studying the work of the behavioral economists.  Marketers never did believe that consumers act in a rational manner. The following notes are from Nudge.   When you have time, I hope you will read the book.   A key idea in the book is that we have two interrelated cognitive systems that......

Words: 10215 - Pages: 41