Oltz vs St. Peters Hospital

In: Social Issues

Submitted By Joyce205
Words 1145
Pages 5
Otiz v. St. Peter's Case Study

Joyce Alston
Grand Canyon University: HTL-520 Legal Issues with Physicians
December 3, 2014

Tafford Oltz was a nurse anesthetist who brought an antitrust action against physician anesthesiologists and the St. Peter’s Community Hospital. This case study involved the violation of antitrust laws deriving from other anesthesiologist in the hospital who not accepted having to compete with Oltz because he was said to have charged rates that were lower and the majority of physicians wanted to use his service. The case study involved the violation of antitrust laws deriving from the law suit issued by Tafford Oltz. (Corrigan and Donaldson, 2000) Oltz was forced out of his position due to illegal competing techniques by other anesthesiology. The agreement Oltz had with St. Peter’s included an agreement with the hospital that Oltz would provide eighty-four percent of his the surgical services. Oltz made the agreement based on the fact that he would be the primary anesthetist during the term of the agreed contract. The hospital was located in a rural community that it served therefore the patient population may have caused a strain on the family to obtain her level of interest. The lawsuit revealed that the other hospital anesthesiologist conspired to and thee competing with the nurse anesthetist’s lower fees and, as a result, entered into an exclusive contract with the hospital on April 29, 1980, in order to squeeze the nurse anesthetist out of the market. This resulted in cancellation of the nurse anesthetist’s contract with the hospital. (Corrigan and Donaldson, 2000) There are many considerations that should be weighed in this case. As employment that has contractual obligations are an anesthesiologist is a physician or a nurse who is certified or licensed to care for a patient prior to, during and after a medical…...

Similar Documents

Home Birth vs. Hospital Birth

...Home Birth vs. Hospital Birth Delivering a baby in the home and in the hospital both provide comfort to some, but homebirth offers decreased cost and hospital births offer more options. Some women have different birthing methods in mind when it comes to delivering a child. Some women feel that it is more convenient to stay home to deliver their child. Mothers-to-be will choose to have a hospital birth because they may feel safer or more secure knowing that if something is not right or if she has had complications, the doctor is there and she is in a hospital and everything will be okay. Are you a mother-to-be? Are you having trouble trying to figure out whether to have a homebirth or a hospital birth? I sure hope that this paper will help you make your final decision. The reason women choose to have a homebirth is because it is more convenient to stay home. She has no bags to pack, long and uncomfortable rides to the nearest hospital, and she does not have any paperwork or registration. Her chosen midwife (a person trained to assist women during childbirth) comes to her when she is ready for her. Of course, it is more convenient after the baby is born as well. She will have all of her own baby items there and there would be no need for her husband to drive home to get the baby clothes or anything. The reason women choose to have a hospital birth is because it is usually more convenient for them. They feel as though all they have to do is pack a few things and head to the...

Words: 1056 - Pages: 5

St James Hospital

...St James Hospital Waste identification and elimination Waste is seen as a wide range of non-added value activities and costs. Waste are evident in material management and in administration systems. a) Purchasing * purchasing administration (too many suppliers) * too many buyers b) Inventory * excess inventory * duplicated inventory * excess materials in standard packs * use of expensive items in lieu of low-cost ones c) Process * process complexity in Urology administration * cancelled appointments in Urology surgery a) Elimination of waste in the purchasing system. Jimmy's relationship with suppliers is changing from a medium-term trading commitment towards a more stable long-term relationship with fewer suppliers. The main challenge appears to be the medical staff's preferences for a wide range of different types of materials. To reduce input variety means standardisation, and this can be achieved by negotiation/persuasion, or by imposition/conflict. Jimmy's Supplies Manager seems to have used the former approach using cross-functional task forces. Suppliers must be assessed for their capability and interest, in order to ensure that they are likely never to fail to deliver as promised. The risks, then, are around the actual dependability and quality of the suppliers. As is emphasized in the case, low cost (of the purchased items) is no longer the predominant issue: long-term value for money in the overall......

Words: 625 - Pages: 3

Johnson vs. Misericordia Community Hospital

...The Case of Johnson vs. Misericordia Community Hospital involves a patient; Mr. Johnson. Who underwent surgery on his hip by Dr. Salinsky at the Misericordia Community hospital. Apparently, during the surgery Dr. Salinsky severed Mr. Johnson’s artery causing a permanent paralytic condition to his right thigh with resultant atrophy and weakness and loss of function. The Plaintiff brought the case to trial on grounds of negligence by the doctor. The hospital however, disputed the allegations of negligence. The court of appeals ruled in favor of the plaintiff. The big issue with the plaintiff’s claim of negligence is that the hospital was held responsible for Dr. Salinsky actions because it was up to the hospital to ensure that patients received the best care by hiring only the most competent employee, which they failed to do. According to the account in our text, Dr. Salinsky was hired without the proper background check. It was found later that Dr. Salinsky’s application contained significant misstatements and omissions that would have otherwise, been cause for denial. Untruths, like stating that he had never been suspended, diminished, revoked, or not renewed. Yet, in another part of his application he failed to reply to the questions pertaining to his malpractice, insurance, carrier, policy number, amount of coverage, He represented that that he had requested privileges only for those surgical procedures in which he was qualified by certification. Mrs. Bekos,......

Words: 460 - Pages: 2

Pujols vs St Louis Cards Neg.

...Problem: Before the beginning of the 2011 season, Albert and the St. Louis Cardinals agreed to a contract deadline. Albert did not want contract negotiations to be a distraction for him during the season and asked that all discussions and offers wait until the end of the season. As asked, we respected Mr. Pujols wishes. Goals: Our goal was to keep Albert in St. Louis. Over the past ten years, he has become an icon to the great city. He is not only the best player in baseball, and on his way to having a Hall of Fame career, but an iconic figure in sports. While in negotiation, we wanted to keep in mind our common goals. Albert and the Cardinals wanted to play great baseball. We wanted them to play great baseball and it was our job to find the best people to do that. We also wanted to negotiate terms that would protect our organization. Going into negotiation, the Cardinals’ goal was to pay a fair price for a player of Albert’s age, ability, and achievements. Knowing his statistics, we expected a hard bargain. Leverage: Pujols received $16 million in 2011. Cardinal management acknowledged he was in line for a raise from that, but the question was how much and for how long. They knew the risk that another team could offer a higher bid that they could not match, but hoped the open market would not be as welcoming as Albert and his agent, Dan Lozano, had hoped. The Cardinals did not have a lot of leverage in this negotiation. They were one of many teams that sought after......

Words: 666 - Pages: 3

Profit vs Non Profit Hospitals

... Profit vs. Non Profit Healthcare Organizations Prepared By: Milton Flores Table of Contents I. Introduction……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………3 II. Definition of Non Profit Health Care Organization………………………………………………………………………….4 III. Definition of Profit Health Care Organization…………………………………………………………………………………4 IV. Issues facing Non Profit and Profit Health Care Organizations……………………………………………………….5 V. Options to improve operations……………………………………………………………………………………………………….6 I. Introduction The debate on whether all healthcare institution should be non-profit rises many issues and they have been heavily debated. The best way to examine this to analyze if non-profit hospitals are in fact better that for profit hospitals and whether there is enough evidence data to support policies dictating ownership. Hospitals in the United States are the largest health care organization in this country. Private hospitals may either be classified as non-profit or for-profit institutions. The majority of the hospitals within the United States are non-profit. The main difference between non-profit and for-profit hospitals is the regulatory rules. Non-profit hospitals are not required to pay property, sales, or income tax. The reason that non-profit hospitals and other organizations were established was with the intention of servicing the needs of the poor. This is the reason that not-for-profit health care and hospitals are exempt from taxes, it was due......

Words: 996 - Pages: 4

Giuliano Bugiardini’s, Madonna and Child with St. John the Baptist, Northern vs. Southern

...Giuliano Bugiardini’s, Madonna and Child with St. John the Baptist, 1510, is a pristine depiction of what Southern European art during the renaissance contained, element by element. Northern artists kept most their roots, focusing heavily on religion while enhancing on the details and adding few aspects of naturalism; while Southern artists took more of a maniera greca and humanistic type approach, where religion and abstraction was in a conflicting battle with what was reality. The color, light, and shadow of Bugiardini’s, Madonna and Child with St. John the Baptist, emits a naturalistic feel that is seen throughout the whole painting. The painting’s main colors of brown and green are abundantly found in nature, usually representing trees, grass, dirt, etc. Mary’s red and blue gown contrasts with the rest of the scenery, making her stand out while emitting a calm (blue) but emotional (red) tone. The colors in the painting also seem to tell a story with a dull, dark brown in most of the foreground, and more vivid greens in the background. This could represent current dark times, followed by a future containing bright, happier times. Many Southern arts contained action in the moment pictures, with dramatic pathos conveying a story or message, which roots back to the Greco Roman influences. The striking contrasts from light to dark, or tenebrism, near Mary’s leg covering was different than the previous gradual chiaroscuro. Jesus and St. John are hit with new, stronger light,......

Words: 1362 - Pages: 6


...Organization Peter F. Drucker Jim Collins, Philip Kotler, James Kouzes, Judith Rodin, V. Kasturi Rangan, and Frances Hesselbein 5 “Nobody, not even Socrates, has ever asked better questions than Peter Drucker. All the personality, all the wisdom is here to make your work dramatically more effective. There’s nothing better. It’s like having Peter at your side.” —Bob Buford, author, Halftime and Finishing Well, and founding chairman, Peter F. Drucker Foundation for Nonprofit Management “Peter Drucker’s penetrating and profound insights are more relevant and needed today than when he originally produced them. This helpful revision of his classic Self-Assessment Tool offers managers and leaders in every sector—nonprofit, business, and government—a useful guide to figuring out what’s needed, why it matters, and how to make it work. At a time when the need for more effective management and more ethical leadership are the moral equivalent of global warming, Drucker’s common sense and courage should be modeled by everyone who cares about doing things right and doing the right thing.” —Ira A. Jackson, dean, Peter F. Drucker and Masatoshi Ito Graduate School of Management, and board member, The Drucker Institute “Peter Drucker’s Five Most Important Questions continue to be the indispensable questions that an organization must ask itself, regardless of size or sector, if it is determined to be an organization of the future. When these questions are asked, the journey begins. And......

Words: 20187 - Pages: 81

Balanced Scorecard at St. Elsewhere Hospital

...Balanced Scorecard at St. Elsewhere Hospital 1. What is the Balanced Scorecard/What is its purpose? - The Balanced Scorecard provides a framework for strategic management by transforming a company’s strategic goals into an integrated collection of objectives and performance indicators. The performance indicators are grouped into four perspectives which include: Financial, Customer, Internal Business Process, and Learning & Growth. Objectives are then formed within each of these perspectives and measures are chosen to create a scorecard that promotes the company’s strategy. The objects and performance measures within each perspective must be linked together. This overall process allows a company’s overall strategy to be transparent to all employees within the organization. 2. Describe each of the four perspectives of the Balanced Scorecard? - Financial Perspective: These are usually associated with profitability. Typical measures could include operating profit, return on assets, and individual product line or customer profit margins. However many other financial measures can be used as they usually differ depending on what industry you are in. - Customer Perspective: These measures include customer satisfaction, customer retention, and new customer acquisition which in turn indicated how well a company is providing value. Understanding what customers value is a big part of this perspective. - Internal Business Process Perspective: In this......

Words: 642 - Pages: 3

Hospital Infection Rates in St Elsewhere

...Methods Design and setting We performed a longitudinal retrospective patient record review study in 21 randomly sampled hospitals in 2004, and 20 in 2008 out of the total of 93 Dutch hospitals. Eight hospitals were studied in both years. Both samples were stratified for hospital type, university, tertiary teaching and general hospitals, and a proper representation of both urban and rural settings in the samples were verified. Tertiary teaching hospitals in The Netherlands provide specialised care and train doctors. The level of care given is between that given in a university hospital and in a general hospital. Generally speaking, university hospitals and, to some extent, tertiary teaching hospitals tend to treat more complex patients with more complex care. To be eligible, hospitals had to have at least 200 beds and an intensive care unit. In each hospital, 400 patient admissions were randomly selected in 2004, and 200 in 2008. Fifty percent of the records were of patients who were discharged from the hospital after a stay of at least 24 h. The other 50% were of patients who died in hospital. These patients were sampled from all inpatient deaths, regardless of their length of stay. We did not exclude patients admitted with an explicitly palliative care plan; this information was noted down and taken into account during the review process. During analysis, overall AE rates were corrected for the oversampling of deceased patients, because in our sample, 50% of the patients......

Words: 5937 - Pages: 24

St. Jude Children's Hospital Outline

...St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital, Finding Cures. Saving Children. Moises Sandoval. Specific Purpose: To persuade the members of my audience in becoming a Partner in Hope by donating/volunteering to St. Jude Children’s Hospital. Thesis Statement: Since 1962, St. Jude hospital has been a symbol of hope for children and families in the need. As one of the world’s premier pediatric cancer research centers, St. Jude hospital continues to provide the quality of research and treatment relying on the support of many donors to continue its lifesaving mission of finding cures and saving children. Organizational Pattern: Monroe’s Motivated Sequence. Introduction (Attention) I. Attention-Getting Device—Eggs dynamic: Draw faces on 4 eggs to make 4 members of the audience figure that those eggs were their children. Then, paint a mark on two of those eggs to show in one of them that the stain represented cancer and we didn’t know what caused it; the mark on the second egg would try to illustrate that we can try to remove the mark (or resolve the problem with cancer) ourselves but we are not able because it is not in our capacity and that would bring us to the breaking of the third egg that would represent that sometimes when we try to resolve so serious problems ourselves such as cancer we would only make it worse. II. Introduce Your Topic—The topic of St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital is introduced in connection with the eggs dynamic by stating to the......

Words: 1104 - Pages: 5


...brothersand siste had a sound eduacation from thier French goveness. His parents sometimes took him to concert. One time after a conert, he would complained that he could not fall asleep because of the music stuck in his head. At age 4, he and sister composed a song for thier mother. At age 6, he was able to read in French and German. He reguraly received piano lessons from his nanny, Fanny Durbach. He was devoted to his mother, when she died when his was 14, it devasted him greatly. That same year he turned to serious compostion. He attented law school in St. Peterburg, Russia, and while studying law and Governement, he took music lesson, including some composing from Gabreial Lomerkin. He graduated at the age of nineteen and took a job as a burea clerk. He worked hard, but he hated his jobl by the time he was totally absorbed by music. He went on to study at the St\. Petersburg Conversatory from 1891-1865. His training at St. Peterburg Conservatory "westernized" his musical tequingue seprating him from the more traditional and nationalistic school of Russia music. He was rgred as one of the greatest Russian composers of the late Romantic period, he also produced theClassical beauty of the 18th Century. His music is professioanl in sound and tequinue. His music has come to be known and loved for its distinctive Russian Character as well as its richharmonies and stirring meoldies. His work, however, were much more western than his Russian contemories as he effectivily used......

Words: 1963 - Pages: 8

St Jude Research Hospital

...Accounting for Not-for-Profit Organizations- St. Jude’s Children’s Research Hospital Tina Crawn Saint Leo University Accounting for Not-for-Profit Organizations- St. Jude’s Children’s Research Not-for-profit organizations are distinguished by characteristics to include receiving contributions of significant amounts of resources from resource providers who do not expect monetary benefits in return, operating for purposes other than to provide services or goods at a profit, and lack defined ownership interest that can be sold, transferred or redeemed. The Financial Accounting Standards Board is also responsible for overseeing not-for-profit organizations and accomplishes this by providing the Accounting Standards Codification or ASC. Not-for-profit organizations account for their revenues, expenses, assets, and liabilities on the full accrual basis of accounting. The financial statements are to provide information that meets the common interests of donors, members, creditors and other resource providers. (Ives, Patton, & Patton, 438). The financial statements required for NFPO include a statement of financial position, a statement of activities, and a statement of cash flows. Revenues, expenses, and investments are all received with certain classifications imposed on them. St. Jude’s Children’s research hospital is a not-for-profit organization founded by entertainer Danny Thomas and opened on February 4, 1962. St. Jude is supported primarily by donations......

Words: 2004 - Pages: 9

Peter Singers Ethics

...Media resource Eidos84. (2010, Nov. 27). Peter Singer’s ethics [Video file]. Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gVViICWs4dM Argument Outline: (CONTEXT): Instead of spending money on things to make life a tad bit easier for others, why do we feel that it is necessary to go above and beyond to spend money on things that are a necessity? Issue: Why do we go overboard on spending money on ourselves instead of giving and helping others with the extra funds we do have and not seeing anything morally wrong with that? Conclusion: We must practice thinking ethically and learn to take in or account the interest of others. Premises: Singer uses an example that someone may decide to buy a pair of shoes that costs over two thousand dollars. If they had to decide between rescuing a drowning child in a shallow pond, they would save the child and they won’t care about ruining a pair of two thousand. However morally, for the price of those shoes, a person could have helped several children in a poor country who may need medical attention to recover from simple illnesses. I believe that this is basis for a good argument because he is absolutely right when he refers to some of our terrible spending habits. Every year I donate to St. Jude Children’s Hospital because I know that it truly helps children in need. Bran new clothes every month for me could be the cost of a child’s medication in another county. Singer goes on to say, “we make our lives most meaningful when we......

Words: 274 - Pages: 2

St. Jude's Research Hospital

...Saint Jude Research Hospital for Children Saint Jude’s Children’s Hospital is one of the largest, fastest growing and most technologically advanced hospitals in the world. They are committed to finding cures for childhood cancers and other catastrophic diseases. They were founded in 1962 by actor Danny Thomas. It’s National Fund Raising campaign is the primary source of funds, along with federal grant money. The mission of St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital is to advance cures, and means of prevention, for pediatric catastrophic disease through research and treatment (Stjudeorg, 2015). This mission is being accomplished daily with the significant research done in the field of pediatric oncology. Founder, Danny Thomas believed that no child should be denied treatment, regardless of the family’s ability to pay and even after his death, no child is turned away. St. Jude has also partnered with other charities such as the Ronald McDonald house to allow families to have an extended stay in its hotel in close proximity to the hospital, so that the family’s financial burden is even further lessened. In 2012 Senator Steve Cohen authored an amendment to the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) that fed 10 Billion dollars into the National Institutes of Health (Housegov, 2015). This organization is responsible for funding research on diseases such as cancer, AIDS, and diabetes. The funds are distributed through an application process. When the ARRA......

Words: 779 - Pages: 4

St. Mary's Honor Center vs. Hicks

...St. Mary’s Honor Center v. Hicks The St. Mary’s Center v. Hicks case created national storm after the Supreme Court decision that an employee must provide evidence and prove discrimination in the workplace. To demonstrate discrimination, an employee must conform under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Cundiff, & Chaitovitz, 1994). Justice Scalia labeled Saint Mary’s Center v. Hicks case “pretext-plus” approach. Other courts, commentators, and analysts originally also classified the term pretext-plus. The approach of this case is similar to “pretext-only” approach from the case McDonnell Douglas Corp v. Green of 1973 (Cundiff, & Chaitovitz, 1994). The employee must develop a discrimination case and accepted as correct and proved otherwise. The employer is then liable and must effectively express the impartial administration. Conversely, if the employer does not provide an explanation to the accusation, the employee who established a charge of racial discrimination wins. Otherwise, if produces a statement of nondiscrimination regarding the allegation, then the employee is accountable and proves that the employer’s affirmation is purely pretextual. Apart from that, if the employee demonstrates pretext, the employer prevails (Cundiff, & Chaitovitz, 1994). Even though it is significant to change the structure of the organization to function efficiently and effectively. Considering the current employees performances and achievements is also significant to avoid legal......

Words: 768 - Pages: 4