Novartis Judgement Report

In: Business and Management

Submitted By spperavali4
Words 2339
Pages 10
Novartis V. Union of India & Others – A Landmark Judgement on Indian Patent Law & Pharmaceutical Industry: A Report

The Supreme Court judement on the Novartis v. Union of India & Others is a landmark decision on the issue of pharmaceutical patent in India. The decision taken after a seven year long litigation fought by pharmaceutical major Novartis is based on a case pertaining to grant of Indian patent on a compound called Imatinib Mesylate in Beta Crystalline Form (referred as Imatinib hereinafter as convenience of brevity). The Supreme Court decided that Imatinib, the substance for which Novartis sought patent does not qualify the test of invention as laid down in section 2(1)(j), section 2(1)(ja) and the test of efficacy under section 3(d) of the Indian Patent Act, 1970. The decision generated widespread discussion and debate on affordability of life saving drugs in India for public good and impact on R&D for further innovation in pharmaceutical industry.

The report covers following contents.

1. Background of the Novartis Case

❖ Fact of the case

❖ Underlying legal provisions

2. Overview of patent law in India with special focus on pharmaceutical industry

3. Supreme Court Decision in Novartis Case

4. Impact of the Supreme Court Judgement

❖ On affordability of life saving drugs

❖ On innovation for future improvement and development

❖ Overall impact on pharmaceutical industry both global & Indian.

5. A Proposition on future strategy for Novartis

Background of the Case

Fact of the Case

In 1996, United States and European patent offices granted patent right to Jurg Zimmerman, the inventor of Imatinib in free base form and derivatives, which was acquired by Novartis for commercial usage. Novartis started manufacturing and selling the drug…...

Similar Documents

Judgement Day

...they could, the national media descended on Littleton, setting up shop and staying there for as long as possible. By the Wednesday after the shooting, the national media had swarmed the area capturing the raw emotion of a devastated community. “Overnight, television crews increased from about 20 on the scene to 100 or 150” (Shepard). All the major networks were there, along with CNN and Fox News. Major newspapers such as the Washington Post, the New York Times and the Los Angeles Times were present too. Littleton was “transformed into Mediaville, a cluttered impromptu town surrounded by more than two dozen satellite trucks, here hundreds of journalists from across the globe have come to report the Big Story” (“Networks Descend”). Even international media from Japan, England and France came to report. “It quickly became a sea of wall-to-wall media” (Shepard). It prompted herd journalism – do anything and everything to get the big story, and get it first. When the public watches the coverage on the news, they never see the hundreds of journalists and massive amounts of equipment cluttering the scene and turning the area into a television set. Media was everywhere. “To get to a tent covering a makeshift memorial, teary-eyed students had to step over tangles of cables that provided the power for television camera lights, and make their way past reporters” (Sink). Residents of Littleton thought the story was in their backyard, a community matter. Instead, it transformed into a......

Words: 5077 - Pages: 21

Last Judgement

...Shabria Rahming Professor Soifer Art History Paper November 23, 2011 The painting I chose to write about was “The Last Judgement” which is a masterpiece by Michelangelo. This painting covers the whole entire wall behind the alter of the Sistine chapel. This is an illustration of the second coming of Christ. In the painting you can tell that Michelangelo was inspired by the Bible, but he also uses his own visual ideas and imagination in this painting. This painting is huge, and its measurements are 48X44 feet. This painting was created between the years of 1536 and1541. This painting was made out of fresco, so Michelangelo had to work fast on this painting so he would be done before it dried. It’s obvious that Michelangelo not only got ideas from the Bible, but he also added some theories from mythology in his painting. For instance, the boatman at the bottom of the painting is the boatman from Roman and Greek mythology that ferried the unsaved to hell, and that’s exactly what he’s doing in this painting. The emotion and frightening looks on the people faces helps show that they’re going to hell. This painting has some other unique features about it. For example, the men and women have very voluptuous body figures. This is how most of the people are painted in Michelangelo’s paintings. I believe this is how people were perceived in his era. This is totally different then how things are in our times. Now women have to be skinny or even anorexic to be perceived as......

Words: 493 - Pages: 2

Novartis Case Study Analysis

...Novartis: Facts 1. Jurg Zimmerman had invented a number of derivatives of N-Phenyl-2-pyrimidine-amine including Imatinab. 2. These derivatives had valuable anti-tumor properties and hence could be used in pharmaceutical compositions for the treatment of human beings against cancer. 3. These derivatives had been granted patent in both the US and Europe. Beginning with Imatinab in its base form. 4. Novartis claims to have developed Beta Crystalline form of Imatinab in a two-stage process and a direct process, with obtaining Imatinab Mesylate in amorphous form as an output in the stage one of the two-stage process. 5. An application was filed for the patent of the beta crystalline form of Imatinab Mesylate in India claiming that the newly invented form had more beneficial flow properties, thermodynamic stability and a lower hygroscopicity than the original Imatinab. 6. Further, they claimed it has better storage properties and that it was easier to process than the Imatinab in basic form. 7. However it was also claimed in the application for patent that all the inhibitory and pharmacological effects of the beta crystalline form of Imatinab Mesylate were also found in the base form of the compound. Novartis: Law Points and Development of the Case 1. When the application was filed for patent in the year 1995,the patent laws in India were under transition phase and as a result the application held in a dormant mode. 2. Later in March 2002, the applicant makes......

Words: 1511 - Pages: 7

False Judgement

...have misjudged a situation. Whether it was assuming someone took your pencil when it is actually in behind you ear, or assuming which character is the killer in our favorite movie, we all have misjudgements all the time in our lives. When was the last time you have mistaken a situation? The theme of false judgement demonstrated in the play “Othello” by Shakespeare, the short story “The Invisible Wound” by Karoly Kisfaludi, and the film “To Kill a Mockingbird”. In these three storylines, the author exhibits the theme of false judgment through a character of innocence that is poorly misjudged and ends tragically for them. Othello accuses his wife, Desdemona of adultery, while the unnamed protagonist in “The Invisible Wound” also inaccurately assumes his wife is cheating. In “To Kill a Mockingbird”, the jury accuses Tom Robinson of a crime that he did not commit all because of the colour of his skin. Given the above, it is clear that these three story lines hold the same theme of an error in judgement occurring. Throughout the play, “Othello” by William Shakespeare, a few of the characters are condemned on untruthful information. Desdemona and Cassio are victims of poor judgement. Accusations towards Desdemona seem to be the most prominent to any reader – which all begin when Othello falls to Iago’s manipulation that causes Othello to poorly judge his own wife. Othello accuses his wife, Desdemona, of adultery. Iago provides “proof” of Desdemona’s unfaithfulness such as Cassio......

Words: 1945 - Pages: 8

Kpmg Professional Judgement

...committees should never be satisfied with the information that they received in prior years. They are demanding more information and it is the responsibility of the auditor to provide this opinion after following the steps that are outlined in this paper. Improvement in judgment processes takes time and over time, the process will become easier. As you improve using the judgment techniques, the result will provide efficiency and provide effective results. Throughout the readings for this paper the goal was always to promote ways to improve professional judgment. Applying the steps to good and effective judgment will enable the auditor to have a successful professional career. Bibliography Chevalier, R. G. (2013). Elevating Professional Judgement in Auditing and Accounting. Hefferon, E. (1980). Suggested approach to the preliminary survey. International Journal of Government Auditing . Hollander, M. (1978). The audit plan-A tool for improving auditing performance. The Practical Accountant , 11(5), 37....

Words: 910 - Pages: 4

Global Talent Management at Novartis

...Global Talent Management at Novartis Individual Case Assignment There are two philosophies of leadership behind Novarits. First was to develop talent for leadership positions from within, which was one of the goals of any talent management system. It was easier to build a company culture when its employees come up through the ranks with shared values and experiences. Also, it was often less expensive to promote from within than to outbid an outside competitor for someone already holding a comparable position. Another element of Vasella’s philosophy was that the company needed to move talented individuals to their desired positions before they were solicited from the outside. Vasella recognized that in order to manage talent successfully, the company needed to pay people well, but he also knew that pay was not enough to motivate people. People work because they believe in the purpose of the company and they feel engaged in its success. From 2002 onward, the entire company adopted the two-dimension scale, with one dimension focusing on business objectives and the other focusing on values and behaviors consistent with Novartis norms. Each of these two performance dimensions had a three-point scale, with 1 indication poor performance dimensions, 2 indicating satisfactory performance, and 3 indicating superior performance. Employees saw their compensation closely connected to company performance and to their individual rating. In order to minimize the criticism of various aspects......

Words: 1562 - Pages: 7

Judgement

...Hana Resa Ananda 141521019 Judgement Judgement is the final step in process of knowing. Before we’ve been learned together about conceptualization as the second process of knowing, and conceptualization considered apart from judgement. Simply allows to us to think the materials provided by sensation and perception. Conceptualization is the beginning of understanding, in that it classifies and relates as such-and-such the this-here-now of sensibility tentatively and hypothetically. The classification must correct and to be verified, that is, it must be shown that the evidence is sufficient to warrant the assertion in each case “it is so”. Only then is knowing complete, for only then is any truth-claim made. Judging Judging is the act of the mind by which a proposition is grasped as virtually unconditioned, that is, as having sufficient evidence for its assertion as true. The first is composition and division. This refers to the act of formulating a proposition in the form: S is (not) P. Proportion is difference language but the meaning, for instance: x. The book is red y. The book is red, these two sentence are same but has difference meaning. Utterances: 2 utterences Propostion: 1 proposition The second role of judgement on this traditional presentation is precisely affirmation or denial of a proposition. Judgement in the full sense requires an answer to the question for reflection, although it supposes an answer to the question for intelligence. The......

Words: 302 - Pages: 2

Transforming Human Resources at Novartis

...Executive Summary: This case demonstrates a scenario of implementing a new system at Novartis in which several variables comes into play. Those variables are cultural differences and lack of organizational innovation. Novartis is facing obstacles on implementing the new HRIS within the organization because it puts pressure on HR associates that interacts with other firms and the company lacks on flexibility and adaptability. The project scope of the implementation is not quite clear and the deadline is too short. In addition, there is a lot resistance by the line managers in the actual implementation of the HRIS since it could increase the difficulties of subsequent implementations and future tasks. There are also cultural differences in communications with other Novartis branches in which can result of misinterpretation that could reduce the effort and commitment of the implementation of the new system. In order for this project to succeed, the senior managers must take action by being actively involved on the implementation of the new system, resolve problems/disagreements and encourage on the implementation of the new system with the line managers. A new company vision would be required and re-structuring the HR department on all branches will be required in order to accommodate the new system, therefore all Novartis branches can work concurrently. 1. What are the major technical, organizational and managerial challenges in the implementation of the HRIS? The major...

Words: 788 - Pages: 4

Novartis Analysis

...OUTPERFORM NOVARTIS Switzerland – Market price at 11/30/2015 closing price: $90.43 DEVAUX Paul, MÉAR Germain – 11/03/2015 Activities: Novartis is the number one pharmaceutical company in the world regarding sales: $47,101 million in 2014. Its headquarters are in Basel, in Switzerland. This company was born from the merger of Ciba-Geigy and Sandoz in 1996. Those companies are both Swiss company with a great history in this sector. The merger of J.R GEIGY LTD and CIBA also formed Ciba-Geigy. Those both companies were founded in Basel In 1758 and 1859. Novartis famous drugs are: • Clozapine (Clozaril) used in the treatment of schizophrenia • Diclofenac (Voltaren) used to reduce inflammation • Pharmaceutical   Industry   Sector   Extreme  (52w))   Lowest   $88.89   Highest   $107.1   Latest  price   $91.04   Vaksartan (Diovan) used to treat high blood pressure Novartis focused first on its pharmaceutical and agrochemical activities and sold other businesses. Novartis is operating directly and through dozens of subsidiaries in countries around the world. There are three key divisions in Novartis: Pharmaceuticals, Alcon and Sandoz. Its pharmaceuticals division aims at providing innovative and important medicines for health needs. It has a portfolio of over sixty medicines, which often are leaders in their therapeutic areas. In addition, this division is currently working on more......

Words: 3850 - Pages: 16

The Judgement of Beauty

...The Judgement of Beauty The judgments of beauty are universally consistent and biologically based, not influenced by culture and individual history. Argue for or against this statement using what you have learned from the course to support your point of view. You may use one or more examples from outside readings to illustrate your points. “Beauty”, as defined in the Oxford Dictionary (2015), is a collection of pleasant qualities, especially those increase the attractiveness of a person or an object. It can be categorized into two different kinds: external beauty and inner beauty (Panek, 2011). External beauty mainly focuses on appearance and body shape (Etcoff, 1999), while inner beauty refers to internal qualities which is considered nice and graceful to others (Perry, 2011). A person described as “beautiful” usually possess a combination of both. While the concept of “inner beauty” is universal, the standard of external beauty is subject to variations (Carla615, 2011), hence would be the main focus of this essay. Some believe that such judgments are universally consistent and based on biological evidence, while others are convinced that culture and one’s individual background may also impact on judgements of beauty. In fact, judgments of beauty are made under a mixed factor of biological intuition, individual history and cultural change. They are not universal across the world. Across centuries, the standard of beauty was always under the influence of culture.......

Words: 1555 - Pages: 7

Global Talent Management at Novartis

...Global Talent Management at Novartis Novartis is one of the largest pharmaceutical companies in the world that spans across 140 countries. Daniel Vasella, CEO, has transformed Novartis into a 100% healthcare company by ridding the company of its specialty chemicals business. By doing so, Novartis became the second largest producer of generic drugs. Vasella reconstructed the company’s approach towards global talent management since the previous approach lacked regular performance review, global objectives, and incentive based pays as a deterrent of motivation. Vasella implemented a universal performance management system and new culture, which is based on candor, performance, and accountability. The key issue involves contradictions with Novartis’s past culture and Vasella’s new culture. The new list of values and behaviors lacks cultural sensitivity and does not reflect the culture that has developed at Novartis. Vasella must implement a plan that includes values and behaviors that are adaptable and based on local cultures to minimize ethnocentrism. Through contingency management, this goal may be achieved because this concept uses management tools and techniques in a situational appropriate behavior, which will avoid the one-best-way mentality. Vasella’s new list of values and behaviors may include: be productive, be innovative, be proactive, be accountable, and be respectful. Top performing companies are more likely to have performance-based rewards, so Vasella......

Words: 303 - Pages: 2

Novartis Hr Practices

...HR Practices in Novartis Bangladesh Contents Executive Summary .................................................................................................................................... 2 Introduction ................................................................................................................................................. 3 Company Background .............................................................................................................................. 3 Mission...................................................................................................................................................... 4 Vision ........................................................................................................................................................ 4 Methodology ................................................................................................................................................ 4 Recruitment ................................................................................................................................................. 5 Selection ....................................................................................................................................................... 6 Basic stages of selection ........................................................................................................................... 6 Tests Measures ...........

Words: 2879 - Pages: 12

Wise Judgement

...Running head: WISE JUDGEMENT Wise Judgement Crystal Davila ENG 106 Survey of Literary Masterpieces University of Phoenix Daphne Matthews May 7, 2012 Wise Judgment There is this teenage girl Michelle who states that she is “in love” with her 17-year-old boyfriend. Her boyfriend is encouraging her to have sex with him saying that he will make sure they only have “protected” sex. The questions that come to my mind is what exactly is protected sex and how does she know she really is in love. At this age, do young adults really understand the true meaning behind love? There are five components of wise judgment and they can be applied to this scenario to understand what is happening and what can be done to help her understand how serious this situation can be. The first component to wise judgment is factual knowledge about matter of life. In this situation, does Michelle really understand what is at steak? This is similar to The Death of Ivan Ilyich when he states “What is the right thing?“ (Tolstoy, 2243). If not she should understand that correct information about protected sex. Even if someone has protected sex does not mean they are one hundred percent safe. Everything that is available for protective sex has warnings printed on them. Just because someone is in love does not mean they have to have sex. On the other hand, if Michelle was not ready and understood what can happen if she does give in to having sex with her boyfriend then she......

Words: 1414 - Pages: 6

Novartis

...ANNUAL REPORT 2010 N OVART I S G R OU P AN N UA L R E PO R T 2 010 OUR MISSION We want to discover, develop and successfully market innovative products to prevent and cure diseases, to ease suffering and to enhance the quality of life. We also want to provide a shareholder return that reflects outstanding performance and to adequately reward those who invest ideas and work in our company. 4 | GROUP REVIEW 19 | H E A LT H C A R E P O R T F O L I O 57 | C O R P O R AT E C I T I Z E N S H I P 8 5 | C O R P O R AT E G O V E R N A N C E 111 | C O M P E N S AT I O N R E P O R T 1 31 | F I N A N C I A L R E P O R T 1 2 N OVART I S G R OU P AN N UA L R E PO R T 2 010 CONTENTS GROUP REVIEW Financial Highlights News in 2010 Letter from Daniel Vasella Interview with Joseph Jimenez 4 5 7 15 19 23 35 39 45 51 57 61 67 73 78 83 85 90 101 111 112 HEALTHCARE PORTFOLIO Contents Pharmaceuticals Novartis Institutes for BioMedical Research Vaccines and Diagnostics Sandoz Consumer Health CORPORATE CITIZENSHIP Contents Commitment to Patients Commitment to People and Communities Commitment to the Environment Commitment to Ethical Business Conduct Independent Assurance Report CORPORATE GOVERNANCE Contents Our Board of Directors Our Management COMPENSATION REPORT Contents Compensation Report NOVARTIS GROUP FINANCIAL REPORT Contents Operating and Financial Review Equity Strategy Novartis Group Consolidated Financial Statements......

Words: 8604 - Pages: 35

Judgement and Decision Making Text Abstracts

...loops’ to identify and treat the systematic weaknesses that contribute to accident occurrence creates an overall safer organisation. In particular, recording and auditing accidents, incidents and unsafe acts alone is not sufficient. Due diligence and effort must be placed into establishing a system of ‘pathogen auditing’, where management practice and decision deficiencies and psychological precursors to unsafe acts are identified and treated. An important, if briefly addressed, point is made regarding hindsight. Reason explains that accidents occur, and while judgement and decision making is easy in hindsight, it is very difficult to identify contributing factors in the moment or prior to an incident. Constant vigilance, willingness to change and sufficient feedback loops are key to a safe organisation. Example The Army takes safety and personal injury very seriously. There are formal mechanisms in place to report injuries of all natures and exposure to a dangerous occurrence where no injuries occurred. Any fatality automatically triggers a high-level inquiry covering causes, responsibilities, risk management and hazard identification. As the paper outlines, this is of minimal use as it is retrospective and cannot change what has already occurred. These measures represents feedback loops one and two, as described in the paper. Additionally, periodic workplace audits, safety committee meetings and other measures seek to prevent unsafe acts. A culture of safety is promoted......

Words: 2564 - Pages: 11