Nike Hitting the Wall

In: Business and Management

Submitted By savage466
Words 1103
Pages 5
Hitting the Wall: Nike and International Labor Practices

1. Does Jeff Ballinger have a convincing argument about Nike? Does Nike have a convincing response?

There is no denying of the fact that Jeff Ballinger has a convincing argument about Nike. As he was assigned to run AAFLI office in Indonesia, he was very much inclined to investigate the labor practices and minimum wage compliance by overseas American companies. Moreover, Nike was in news at that time regarding its critical labor practices, so it became the only prominent target. Ballinger, during the course of his studies about the company and research about the labor practice, revealed that Nike encouraged its contractors to hit some unrealistic production quotas by mistreating the labors. It was also revealed that there were heavy traces of corruption which was degrading the law practices and there were hardly any prosecutions made. According to him, Indonesian workers were paid so low that it hardly fulfilled their basic necessities. The comparison between the pay stub of Indonesian factory and Michael Jordan endorsement contract was even harder hitting based on his technical calculations. According to his report, an average Indonesian worker would take 44,492 years to match the money made by Michael Jordan's one endorsement contract. Followed by the extreme media coverage on this, CBS found that Indonesian workers were only paid 19 cents an hour. Despite hiring Ernst & Young to carry on the audits in the factories, Nike could not resist the criticism coming their way. Initially Nike's response to all this was very unstable. The company took no responsibility of the poor working conditions in the factories. They continued to emphasize that they have nothing to do with the management of the contractors. But as the criticism kept on mounting about the labor practices followed in factories, Nike took…...

Similar Documents

Multinational Strategy Nike Case

...potential offered by developing countries in terms of manpower often less expensive than in their countries of origin. Moreover, the deregulation policies pursued in United States during the '80s, have offered to the multinationals more freedom of action and more opportunities around the world. Asia was the cradle of the first movement led by multinationals offshoring, in their search for productive economy. However, this labour has often been misused, paid with low wages, often composed of children, and working conditions which violate international labour laws. It therefore appears that the use of labour from developing countries has been increasingly criticised by humanitarian organisations, consumers and governments of developed countries. The Nike case studies highlights the problems posed by the massive offshoring politics conducted by the multinational since the 80s, particularly in Asia. An important number of errors have been made by the multinational companies in terms of human rights, international rules of labour, but also the respect of the environment, put back into question the policies of deregulation. We can add to this the recent economic crisis, which put back into question the concept of deregulation. The purpose of this essay is to analyze the reasons that led to such errors. But also to understand why in the current economic context, the regulation is preferred, especially for the safety of the workers in developing countries. 3 The globalisation......

Words: 2306 - Pages: 10

Nike

...Nike, Inc. Internal Memo Subject: Porsche Powers Profit With Currency Plays To: Mr. Mark Parker, President and Chief Executive Officer From: Hongjie Pan, Assistant Chief Financial Officer On October 9, 2012, I attended a conference, and the speaker gave a presentation about a report entitled “Porsche Powers Profit With Currency Play”. This report was written by Stephen Power, and it was published in The Wall Street Journal on December 8, 2004. I would like to share what techniques this multi-international company is using to maximize their wealth. The main point of the report was that Porsche used its profit to do investments and hedged the appreciation of the US dollar. Porsche had a great market share in the United States and lots of revenue came from US buyers in US dollars. The Porsche Company betted that US dollars would drop so they bought put options to prevent the currency loss. I suggest Nike should learn from Porsche, and buy call options to prevent currency loss. From the presentation, I found out that Porsche gain more than 80% of the profit of a fiscal year by hedging in 2003. According to the article, “or up to 800 million euros ($1.07 billion) of the 1.1 billion euros Porsche reported for the fiscal year that ended July 31 – came from skillfully executing options.” It showed how important hedging was. Porsche made the right bet on US dollar depreciation in 2004. Porsche not only earned money by hedging the week US dollar, but also using new technology......

Words: 635 - Pages: 3

Hitting the Wall

...Hitting the Wall: Nike and International Labor Practices Synopsis of The Situation Based in Beaverton, Oregon, Nike had been a corporate success story for more than three decades. It was a sneaker company, but one armed with an inimitable attitude, phenomenal growth, and the apparent ability to dictate fashion trends to some of the world’s most influential consumer. Selling a combination of basic footwear and street-smart athleticism, Nike pushed its revenues from a 1972 level of $62,000 to a starting $49 million in just 10 years. In the 1980s and 1990s, Nike had been plagued by a series of labor incidents and public relations nightmares; underage workers in Indonesian plants, allegations of coerced overtime in China, dangerous working conditions in Vietnam. For a while, the stories had been largely confined to labor circles and activist publications, until a young female worker had died in a Nike contracting factory in 1997, the labor conditions at Nike had hit the mainstream.   While the marketing of Nike’s products was based on selling a high profile fashion item to affluent Americans, the manufacture of these sneakers was based as an arms-length and often-uneasy relationship with low paid, non-American workers. Key Issues Nike's strategy of shaving costs caused ethical dilemmas that ultimately damaged its reputation.  Nike outsources all of its manufacturing. This approach has provided Nike with huge profits, from a 1972 level of $60,000 to a startling $49 million......

Words: 2138 - Pages: 9

Hitting the Wall: Nike

...Hitting the Wall: Nike & international labor practices How well and how responsibly do you think she has handled these issues to date? What advice would you give her about how she should now proceed? What principles should guide the company’s policies and practices? What opportunities, constraints, and risks does the firm face? What are the scope and limits of its social responsibilities? There are two aspects to look at how Nike has acted: 1) The intension with which it has acted: any corporate’s acts are a manifestation of the values of individuals responsible for making decisions. In my view the most relevant reading that applies to Nike is Kant’s philosophy of acting in good will to others and out of moral duty. Kant believes people should respect the rights and dignity of others. However, by having a supplier selection criterion, which focuses on lowest cost and does not include any information on how the goods are manufactured, by who, where they come from, and how the supplier manages such a low cost, Nike has committed a serious oversight of its duties and moral responsibilities. In the process it has acted in sheer self-interest and has ignored the workers’ rights and dignity. It becomes even more important in Nike’s case because it commands a really high bargaining power and could have easily got any information it wanted. Even though, Nike has done a commendable job at course correcting in response to the public criticism - by employing outside firms......

Words: 1343 - Pages: 6

Nike Case Analysis

...REV: SEPTEMBER 6, 2002 DEBORA L. SPAR Hitting the Wall: Nike and International Labor Practices Moore: Twelve year olds working in [Indonesian] factories? That’s O.K. with you? Knight: They’re not 12-year-olds working in factories... the minimum age is 14. Moore: How about 14 then? Does that bother you? Knight: No. — Phil Knight, Nike CEO, talking to Director Michael Moore in a scene from documentary film The Big One, 1997. Nike is raising the minimum age of footwear factory workers to 18… Nike has zero tolerance for underage workers. 1 — Phil Knight, 1998 In 1997, Nguyen Thi Thu Phuong died while making sneakers. As she was trimming synthetic soles in a Nike contracting factory, a co-worker’s machine broke, spraying metal parts across the factory floor and into Phuong’s heart. The 23 year-old Vietnamese woman died instantly.2 Although it may have been the most dramatic, Phuong’s death was hardly the first misfortune to hit Nike’s far-flung manufacturing empire. Indeed, in the 1980s and 1990s, the corporation had been plagued by a series of labor incidents and public relations nightmares: underage workers in Indonesian plants, allegations of coerced overtime in China, dangerous working conditions in Vietnam. For a while, the stories had been largely confined to labor circles and activist publications. By the time of Phuong’s death, however, labor conditions at Nike had hit the mainstream. Stories of reported abuse at Nike plants had been carried in publications......

Words: 9469 - Pages: 38

Nike Case

...Hitting the Wall: Nike and International Labor Practices CEO Phil Knight took a different approach than competitors when it came to his original strategy for Nike. One of the noticeable differences was the outsourcing of all manufacturing; no in-house production or dedicated manufacturing lines. None of the products or manufacturing would be done within the United States, meaning there were no physical assets. The plan to outsource specifically targeted low cost parts of the world. With the amount of money saved by outsourcing they could pour it all into marketing the brand. Celebrity endorsements were used, but in a different fashion because they only used high profile athletes as a representation for Nike. While this strategy was unique and worked well for a while, in the 1990’s problems began to surface. Jeff Ballinger’s main concern was the large gap in wage rates between developed and developing countries. As part of his research he interviewed workers and noted their dissatisfaction with the conditions they worked under. Ballinger believed Nike was more focused on competitive pricing that it led to mistreating workers and expecting unrealistic production. He was concerned Nike employees were not being paid enough in order to fulfill everyday necessities. Ballinger’s work went fairly unnoticed until Indonesia had a sweep of strikes that matched up with his arguments of the company. Nike’s response to the criticism and negative publicity was the contract factories......

Words: 715 - Pages: 3

Hitting the Wall: Nike and International Labor Practices

...success with the Nike Company. I believe that Nike will continue to grow and be successful in the future. However, with the recent concern of foreign labor abuse growing, I accept your request and would be happy to share with you my opinion on what Nike should do next. I will start by elaborating on the general, specific, and changing environments Nike is facing right now and will continue to face in the future. I will then share my recommendations in how to keep Nike afloat and out of the negative public eye. First and foremost, the general environment for many large corporations in the United States have moved portions of their factories overseas to avoid the working regulations in the United States. In the past, Nike has outsourced to several low-income countries such as South Korea, Taiwan, and currently has manufactures in China and Indonesia. As we both know, the purpose in doing so is to receive readily available, cheap labor. Revenues have reached over $9 billion and until recently, Phil Knight’s (Nike CEO) plan to outsource to the poorest countries has worked. However, it has recently become common knowledge to the public that the working conditions in these foreign factories are below the ethical standards. More specifically, the press is beginning to criticize Nike’s offshore exercises and advocacy groups are beginning to emerge. Jeff Ballinger, a labor activist and Nike’s original critic, compared a pay-stub from Indonesian factory to a Nike endorsement......

Words: 760 - Pages: 4

Nike

...corporate citizenship. Through a case study of Nike, Inc. – a company that has come to symbolize both the benefits and the risks inherent in globalization – this paper examines the various difficulties and complexities companies face as they seek to balance both company performance and good corporate citizenship in today’s global world. 1. The Athletic Footwear Industry The athletic footwear industry experienced an explosive growth in the last two decades. In 1985, consumers in the United States alone spent $5 billion and purchased 250 million pair of shoes.2 In 2001, they spent over $13 billion and bought over 335 million pair of shoes.3 Although the industry is highly segmented – by different sports, models and price – the branded shoe segment is dominated by a few large companies Miguel Korzeniewicz, “Commodity Chans and Marketing Strategies: Nike and the Global Athletic Footwear Industry,” in Gary Gereffi and Miguel Korzeniewicz, eds., Commodity Chains and Global Capitalism, (Greenwood Press, 1994): 248. 3 National Sporting Goods Association, 2002; www.sbrnet.com 2 2 (e.g., Nike, Reebok, Adidas). In fact, the top 10 footwear companies control over 70% of the global athletic footwear market. (See Table 1). Since displacing Adidas in the early 1980s and Reebok in the early 1990s, Nike has become the largest and most important athletic shoe company in the world. (See Figure 1). Table 1: Market Share Athletic Footwear Market Share Nike Reebok Adidas Fila Converse New......

Words: 7820 - Pages: 32

Nike

...NIKE, Inc NIKE, Inc. (NYSE: NKE) is an American multinational corporation giant who sells high quality footwear, apparel, and equipment accessories and service. HISTORICAL EQUITY PERFORMANCE: Nike has always been riding the wave and moved from strength to strength. If we look at the trading charts, obviously, there have been decline periods with Stock Market falls but that has been few and far between. Upon close observation, the only lull period in this century the stock has seen would be between 2000-2002 and the year 2005, except that there has been terrific performance of the company on the stock exchange. Mr. Mark Parker, Nike’s President and CEO said in a statement that "Fiscal year 2015 is off to a strong start. Our connection to consumers and ability to innovate, combined with our powerful global portfolio, is a complete offense; Nike has never been better positioned to realize our tremendous growth potential." (cnbc, 2014) After many years of stellar growth, the indication has been coming from the management that there is a bump up from the Football World Cup. As the company reported its first result after World Cup, the company indicated that it has found new growth pillars and they would be able to bank on that. Results in nearly all segments and geographies improved. Credit Suisse (CS) upgraded the stock and increased the price targets to $100. (Market watch, 2014) It's taking so much market share from competitors that Adidas's CEO even had to defend his......

Words: 1013 - Pages: 5

Nike

...Nike Dwayne Wood June 7, 2014 Professional Communications Strayer University Dwayne Wood, Professional Consultants Inc. 5454 Executive Way – Virginia Beach, VA 23456 http://www.professonalconsultants.com 07 June 2014 Mr. Mark Parker, CEO Nike Inc. 1 Bowerman Dr. Beaverton, OR 97005 Dear Mr. Parker: This document presented to you is a presentation requested from my President on how Professional Consultants Inc., could help Nike Inc. come up with a strategy of how to create a cheaper brand. We know how important the bottom line is to your company and that is why we already have associates working on impact statements and balance sheets for your company. This report shows that with a small investment and a little research, together we could create a brand that is affordable for low income families. Creating a brand that low income families can afford, would further extend the company while making millions of dollars. Professional Consultants Inc. knows that Nike has a very strong brand we just want to make it stronger, also while helping people that cannot afford the Nike brand, able to afford a much cheaper brand. It is with great pleasure in preparing this report for you, Mr. Parker, and while working on it I have learned many different elements about the shoe business and about Nike Inc. Please call me directly at (757)466-2000 when I can be of further service. Sincerely, Dwayne Wood Associate Consultant Table of Contents Title......

Words: 1568 - Pages: 7

Nike Case Study

...Nike Case Study Shiffaun L. Alston Jack Welch Management Institute Professor R. Chua JWMI 550 Sunday, December 7, 2014 Executive Summary Nike’s business model was based in outsourcing its manufacturing, then using the money it saved on aggressive marketing campaigns. However, the process of outsourcing work internationally proved to be problematic for Nike in a variety of ways particularly in regards to low wages provided workers and poor working conditions and environment. This paper intends to evaluate Jeff Ballinger’s argument against Nike, as well as determine how convincing Nike’s response was to Ballinger’s allegations. Lastly, strategies are provided as to how Nike moves forward after the smoke of the crisis has cleared. Evaluation of Jeff Ballinger’s argument against Nike Ballinger’s main argument that “any company has a significant obligation towards even its lowliest workers” is a very convincing one on many levels—social, ethical, and financial. Companies, such as Nike, make large profits and benefit tremendously from workers’ low wages in their international manufacturing companies. After reviewing Exhibit 1 (Nike Inc. Financial History 1989-1999) and Exhibit 4 (Summary of Revenue and Expense Profile of Minimum Wage Workers by Demographic Type) it would appear that Nike could indeed offer its workers higher wages at least to a level where workers can survive and help their families, some additional benefits, and......

Words: 1688 - Pages: 7

Nike

...Nike, Inc. (pronounced /ˈnaɪkiː/; NYSE: NKE) is a major publicly traded sportswear and equipment supplier based in the United States. The company is headquartered near Beaverton, Oregon, which is part of the Portland metropolitan area. It is the world's leading supplier of athletic shoes and apparel[3] and a major manufacturer of sports equipment with revenue in excess of US$19.014 billion (FY 2010. As of 2008, it employed more than 34,400 (May 2010) people worldwide. Nike and Precision Castparts are the only Fortune 500 companies headquartered in the state of Oregon, according toThe Oregonian. The company was founded on January 25, 1964 as Blue Ribbon Sports by Bill Bowerman and Philip Knight,[1] and officially became Nike, Inc. on May 30, 1978. The company takes its name from Nike (Greek Νίκη pronounced [nǐːkɛː]), the Greek goddess of victory. Nike markets its products under its own brand as well as Nike Golf, Nike Pro, Nike+, Air Jordan, Nike Skateboarding and subsidiaries including Cole Haan, Hurley International, Umbro andConverse. Nike also owned Bauer Hockey (later renamed Nike Bauer) between 1995 and 2008.[4] In addition to manufacturing sportswear and equipment, the company operates retail stores under the Niketown name. Nike sponsors many high profile athletes and sports teams around the world, with the highly recognized trademarks of "Just do it" and the Swoosh logo. SWOT Analysis Nike, Inc. Strengths. * Nike is a very competitive organization. Phil Knight...

Words: 4841 - Pages: 20

Case Analysis on Nike

...Study Analysis (Hitting the Wall: Nike and International Labor Practices ) Business Ethics (MBA-513) Section: 02 Case Summary Nike is global footwear for athletes and non-athletes. It is still a highly successful athletic shoemaker today. Based in Beaverton, Oregon, Nike had been a corporate success story for more than three decades. It was a sneaker company, but one armed with an inimitable attitude, phenomenal growth, and the apparent ability to dictate fashion trends to some of the world’s most influential consumers. Selling a combination of basic footwear and street-smart athleticism, Nike pushed its revenues from a 1972 level of $62,000 to a startling $49 million in just ten years. Many researchers believe that Nike went in decline due to two reasons: Michael Jordan’s final retirement and the slowing economy. Another aspect of Nike that has brought a negative image upon them is the negative accusations of exploiting foreign child labor with lower wage. Poor labor conditions and low wages have been an issue for many years, and are still present in 2011.In the 1980s and 1990s, Nike had been plagued by a series of labor incidents and public relations nightmares: underage workers in Indonesian plants, allegations of coerced overtime in China, dangerous working conditions in Vietnam. For a while, the stories had been largely confined to labor circles and activist publications, until a young female worker had died in a Nike contracting......

Words: 3349 - Pages: 14

The Wall

...Corinne Lafalmme-Wathey Professor Keough Critical Writing 120 3 March 2015 “America at War Paper 2” In Jean-Paul Sartre’s “The Wall” there are the five stages of death demonstrated to the audience through what Juan, Tom and Pablo are experiencing. The five stages of death are as follows: denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance. The main reason for all their actions and the ways in which they are reacting to the situation are based around fear. We are able to distinguish a slight difference between the two Tom and Pablo and the young child, Juan. Pablo and Tom’s main fear is concentrated on the physical and emotional pain and suffering that will come from being executed, while Juan simply remains cornered in the cell, in an emotionless state one could say, because he is being executed for something he is not responsible for. Sartre provides his readers with a great deal of detail about the emotions and physical reactions that the three experience as it gets closer to the morning of their execution. Along with the feeling of fear, there are many more ways in which the three respond to such a traumatizing situation. The first stage of death is known as denial. It is clearly shown in the beginning of the night that the three of them are unable to accept the fact that they have been sentenced to death and even more so that little Juan has been as well. It is naturally a hard notion to grasp for the mind and the body of someone who is currently alive, with...

Words: 1024 - Pages: 5

Walls

...和路雪(中国)有限公司:初创期物 流运作 Walls (China) Co., Ltd.: Logistics Operations Startup By Peter Gilmour Professor of Management 和路雪(英文:Wall's)为英 国著名冰激凌企业,总部设在 英国,在全球拥有多家分公 司。是联合利华旗下企业。其 在中国生产的冰激凌品牌是 “ 和路雪”。1993年,和路雪 (中国)有限公司成立。 of: Macquarie University Australia This case was prepared as a basis for class discussion rather than to illustrate effective or ineffective handling of an administrative situation. LOGISTICS CASE STUDY DEVELOPED F OR : COUNCIL OF LOGISTICS MANAGEMENT Walls (China) Co., Ltd. Logistics Operations Startup In mid 1994 the Unilever company Walls (China) Co started manufacturing and selling ice cream in China. Bob Smith, the General Manager of Wall’ outlined some of the s challenges: Operating in China means a number of new concepts for the Chinese managers -profit, selling and customer service. The Chinese manager of the past sat in his office and the customers came to him. It was absolutely a supply driven market. I read in an official report some time ago a list of phrases that should not be used when talking to customers. The list included “Go away and don’ waste my time’ t and ‘ Can’ you hear? Are your ears dirty?’This has now changed and a key to t success is getting our product out to the customers. Distribution costs here are 20 per cent of MPS compared to 5 per cent in Europe. As Loic Courant, Bob Smith’ Commercial Manager in Shanghai, summarized the s situation: He who wins logistics wins China. Unilever in China Unilever is an Anglo-Dutch company......

Words: 7441 - Pages: 30