Discussing Frame Semantics: the State of the Art

In: English and Literature

Submitted By korni
Words 9885
Pages 40
John Benjamins Publishing Company

This is a contribution from Review of Cognitive Linguistics 8:1
© 2010. John Benjamins Publishing Company
This electronic file may not be altered in any way.
The author(s) of this article is/are permitted to use this PDF file to generate printed copies to be used by way of offprints, for their personal use only.
Permission is granted by the publishers to post this file on a closed server which is accessible to members (students and staff) only of the author’s/s’ institute, it is not permitted to post this PDF on the open internet.
For any other use of this material prior written permission should be obtained from the publishers or through the Copyright Clearance Center (for USA: www.copyright.com).
Please contact rights@benjamins.nl or consult our website: www.benjamins.com
Tables of Contents, abstracts and guidelines are available at www.benjamins.com


Discussing frame semantics:
The state of the art
An interview with Charles J. Fillmore
József Andor

University of Pécs

J.A.: Thank you, Chuck, very much for accepting my invitation for this interview.
I would like to center it around the notion of frame, a conceptually valid notion of interdisciplinary relevance, as pointed out by all of the speakers, including ourselves, of an important international colloquium that took place at the oldest university of the Old World, in Bologna in 2005 (Rossini Favretti, 2008). As a sort of father of research elaborating on the conceptual as well as the linguistic relevance, the status of the notion of frames, you were invited to that interdisciplinary conference by its organizers with the aim to give the keynote speech, based on your work devoted to outlining the linguistic theory of frames and also to investigating their role in linguistic representation (Fillmore, 2008). You have been working

Similar Documents

Postmodern Frame Essay - Text in Art.

...The use of text within to the visual arts can be traced back as far as the inscribed carvings found on cave walls created by the Indigenous population of Australia approximately 46000 years ago. However, over the past few years, the use of text in art, also known as the art of typography, has become a frequent means of communication for artists in the creation of their works. Text within art can be projected, scrawled, painted, computerised and carved to the point that a work may be created of nothing but language. The art of typography is the technique of arranging type in such a way that makes language visible. It treats fonts as individual entities to be enjoyed by the audience. Some artists deal with language as a character on its own as opposed to a surface to draw upon. These artists place texts in ways that are intended to stimulate the way an audience perceives a work, to evoke emotion or to create a statement. However, others, particularly graphic designers, tend to focus on the decorative powers of text. Regardless of the artist’s intentions, the appearance of text within art can shift our appreciation of their sound and meaning. Artists that explore text in art include: Barbara Kruger, Yukinori Yanagi, Katarzyna Kozyra, Jenny Holzer, Wenda Gu, Shirin Neshat, Miriam Stannage, Colin McCahon and Jenny Watson. Artists such as Jenny Holzer, Wenda Gu and Shirin Neshat explore the cultural implications of language in art and the importance of language to identity......

Words: 1913 - Pages: 8

The Art of Social Protest

...l.com The Art of Social Protest: “The Raft of the Medusa” and “Guernica”   Some people are advocates of the opinion that art designed to influence social behavior is reprehensible, dirty, nothing more than propaganda, and so on. However, it is impossible to present a complete picture of art if we ignore its function of a social protest; the history of art provides us with many examples. Painting can be an extremely powerful form of protest against inequity, atrocity or inequality. Traditionally, painting is usually supportive of the political needs of old-established order because it is backed up and bought by wealthy people, and thus painting is less willing to engage in social controversies. However, certain artists stand out as exceptions. Among them are two great figures in the history of world painting Théodore Géricault (1791–1824), one of the French pioneers of the Romantic movement, exposing a great contemporary scandal in “The Raft of the Medusa”, and an Andalusian-Spanish painter Pablo Picasso (1881–1973), expressing his fury at the bombing of a peaceful town during the Spanish Civil War (1936-1939) in his painting “Guernica”. Although these two painters differ by origin, style, artistic expression, their works mentioned above have very much in common. Géricault’s “The Raft of the Medusa”  and Picasso’s “Guernica” are perhaps the most significant paintings of social protest in our time. Both paintings are based on real tragic events. However, their creators......

Words: 2068 - Pages: 9


...CURRICULUM MAJOR: ENGLISH COURSE DESCRIPTION 1. General Info: - Course: English Semantics - Code: LI005 - Credits: 2 - Option: Compulsory - Prerequisite: Listening, Speaking, Reading, Writing from 1 to 3 - Requirements: Students are required to attend the class fully, to participate in class activities such as exercises, mini-tests, discussion, etc. based on their self-study in accordance with their lecturers’ guidance and assignment. - Credit hours: + Lecture: 30 periods + Self-study: 45 hours - Department: Department of Foreign Languages – Linguistics Division 2. Objectives - Knowledge: to introduce students to all the main elements of Semantics in a simple step-by-step fashion. - Skills: to provide students with an opportunity to discover the value and fascination of studying Semantics, and move on to such topics as sense and reference, basic sense relations, simple logic, word meaning, and interpersonal meaning. - Attitude: to provide students with an opportunity to develop and promote their apt selfstudy and scholarship 3. Course summary This course has been carefully planned to introduce students to most of the main elements of Semantics. Students begin by discovering the value and fascination of studying Semantics, and move on to such topics as sense and reference, basic sense relations, simple logic, word meaning, and interpersonal meaning. Each unit of the course book used “Semantics A Course book” by James R. Hurford and Brendan Heasley includes short......

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Basic Semantics

...Becky Vella Muskat LIN 1180 Semantics Assessment type: Assignment Date: February 28th 2011 Table of Contents Distinguish between sense, reference and denotation 3 Outline the main features of Prototype Theory and show how it differs from the classical view of concepts as necessary and sufficient conditions. Give examples to support your answer 5 To what extent would you expect people who speak different languages to display fundamental differences in the way they think and perceive the world? Support your answer with examples from one particular domain, such as that of colour terms or number words 7 Bibliography 9 Distinguish between sense, reference and denotation I answer this question in an attempt to draw a distinction between sense, reference and denotation. While doing my research I discovered a clearly defined line between sense and reference, however the line between reference and denotation seems slightly hazier and thus somewhat more difficult to define. The only analogy I can think of, is trying to compare chopsticks to a fork and knife. How does one distinguish between two entities that are essentially the same functionally yet, intrinsically different? This essay is an attempt to make this distinction, by defining denotation before drawing a contrast to reference and sense respectively. A clear definition of denotation can be understood through Saussure’s (1959) explanation of the signification (concept) and signal (sound......

Words: 2291 - Pages: 10

State-of-Art Computer Program

...State-Of-Art Student Name: Indi Class/Section: CMIS Professor Name: Assignment due date: Problem Statement Calculate the total price to purchase all the components required to build a "State-of-the-Art" Gaming computer with option choices limited to three different components. Once the consumer adds up components to the Cart it will create shipping and state taxes (where to ship or billing address) before the final price. Options available for newegg.com Computer Hardware CPU (CPU1/CPU2/CPU3) Intel Core i5-3570K Ivy Bridge 3.4GHz - CPU1 - $224.99 Intel Core i7-4770 Haswell 3.4GHz - CPU2 - $309.99 Intel Core i7-3770K Ivy Bridge 3.5GHz - CPU3 - $329.99 CASE (CS1/CS2/CS3) Corsair Graphite Series 230T - CS1 - $79.99 Case Rosewill THOR V2 Gaming ATX - CS2 - $129.99 CM Storm Trooper - Gaming Full Tower Computer - CS3 - $149.99 PSU (PSU1/PSU2/PSU3) Corsair Graphite Series 230T - PSU1 - $59.99 Cooler Master Elite 430 - PSU2 - $49.99 Rosewill Blackhawk Gaming - PSU3 - $89.99 Motherboard (MB1/MB2/MB3) Asus Maximus vi Hero LGA 1150 Intel - MB1 - $199.79 ASRock Fatal1ty B85 Killer LGA 1150 Intel - MB2 - $104.99 Gigabyte GA-X79-UP4 LGA 2011 Intel X79 - MB3 - $242.99 HDD (HDD1/HDD2/HDD3) Seagate Hybrid Drive ST1000DX001 1TB MLC/8GB 64MB Cache SATA 6.0Gb/s NCQ 3.5" Desktop SSHD Seagate Hybrid Drive ST1000DX001 1TB - HDD1 - $96.99 Seagate Hybrid Drive ST2000DX001 2TB - HDD2 - $129.99 WD Black Series WD3003FZEX 3TB - HDD3 - $194.99 RAM......

Words: 1111 - Pages: 5


...Professor Jeffrey Robinson August 20, 2013 Abstract In this discussion we look at some of the history around frame-relay. We then look at some of the equipment necessary to create the frame relay connections, as well as how the connections work both logically and physically. Some limiting factors are discussed as well as committed information rates, burst rates, an error handling. Some of the positive aspects of frame-relay are identified along with some options for the future of WAN technologies. Frame-Relay Operating at the physical and datalink layers of the OSI model, frame relay is a high-performing WAN protocol. It was originally designed for use with ISDN integrated services digital network interfacing. It has evolved into being used on multiple types of network interfaces. In 1984 the initial proposal for frame-relay standardization was presented to the CCITT Consultative Committee on international telephone and telegraph. Because interoperability standards were lacking, frame-relay did not fully take off until the 1990s. In 1990 StrataCom, Northern Telecom, Digital Equipment Corporation (DEC), and Cisco created a consortium that focused on the technical development of frame-relay technology. While the CCITT was already discussing frame-relay, the consortium established specifications that while still conforming to the frame-relay protocol, enhanced the protocol with additional features to accommodate more complex......

Words: 2574 - Pages: 11

Arizona State University Art Museum

...I decided to attend the ASU (Arizona State University) Art Museum. It is located on Mill Avenue and 10th Street. I had actually expected the museum to be much larger. It consisted of three main levels made up of five different exhibits. Also, on top of the museum was a roof gallery which held the sculpture part of the museum. When I walked into the museum, the first gallery I visited was called the Lower Level South Gallery. This gallery was very unique and contained many beautiful Japanese paintings. When I read about them, I found out these paintings were inspired by the Japanese-American movement. The next gallery I visited was the Turk Gallery. This gallery was mostly filled with paintings as well. However, there were two figures in the middle of the gallery as well as a wooden stamp. The first figure that caught my attention was a bicycle made solely of woven-together straw. The next figure was a large horse made entirely of scrap pieces of metal. I continued on upstairs and found the Americas gallery which was filled with paintings that reflected how America developed over time. Each painting seemed to reflect on specific important times in American history. One wall was covered with paintings of significant leaders in American history. The next gallery was the Kresge Gallery. These walls were covered with pictures of tires that helped advertise certain products. Covering the floor of the gallery were a bunch of bicycles with strange objects (such as plants) connected......

Words: 761 - Pages: 4

African Art

...Yorùbá language with a view to highlighting the stylistic and communicative potentials of these metaphors. To achieve the set objective, the animals – domestic and wild – involved in metaphors and their individual distinctive characteristic features that motivate their metaphorical interpretations are highlighted. The paper also discusses the sources of animal metaphors, which are said to be located in three areas, namely: the Yorùbá naming culture, animal characteristic habits and behaviour, and the Yorùbá poetry. In discussing the metaphorical processes involved in the interpretation of animal-related metaphors, a two-dimensional approach is adopted: stylistic and cultural. In the first, the semantic features of animals involved in metaphors are decomposed into semantic markers that are of two types. The first is the High Priority Semantic Markers (HPSM), which determine the cognitive/conceptual meaning of the metaphors, and the second is the Low Priority Semantic Markers (LPSM), which determine the secondary metaphorical interpretation. Animal metaphors involve transference of meanings, and whatever meanings or interpretations are assigned to a particular animal metaphor, are culture and context dependent. The paper concludes with stylistic and communicative functions of animal metaphors, with the submission that stylistically animal metaphors contribute to aesthetics and poetic elegance of literary texts through their lexical tones, which can be stylistically manipulated.......

Words: 6152 - Pages: 25


...decreases this semantic biases. Finally, her findings with English speakers briefly trained in vertical spatiotemporal metaphors indicated that it was language and not cultural differences that directs one’s way of thinking as they produced results similar to the Mandarin speakers (Boroditsky, 2001). Thus, according to Boroditsky, her findings suggest that language does have a strong influence in shaping habitual thoughts (2001), thereby supporting the linguistic relativity claim. J Y Chen (2006) countered Boroditsky’s claim, stating that a repetition of Boroditsky’s testing in Taiwan with native Mandarin and English speakers did not support her claims nor replicate similar findings. Chen’s findings suggested that the use of horizontal spatial metaphors to indicate temporal relations by Chinese speakers was actually more prevalent than the use of vertical metaphors (2006). He concluded that the findings indicated that Chinese speakers do not think about time differently from English speakers. Chen indicated that the researchers’ lack of competence in Mandarin when examining cross-language issue could have led to the erroneous conclusions by Boroditsky. In my own experience as a bilingual speaker, I find that I am hardly conscious about the differences in usage when talking about time. Even though I grew up in a Mandarin-speaking family, learning English only at preschool age, I find that I am able to switch my mode of thinking according to my target language. When......

Words: 1033 - Pages: 5

Discussing Animal Research

...arguments made in regards to the use of animals in behavioral and biomedical research and the benefits of facilitating classroom room discussions amongst psychology students concerning this controversial topic. 2. Introduction Herzog H.A, (1990) believed that since the publishing of Singer’s book, Animal Liberations, in 1975, public concern over the ethical treatment of animals has significantly risen (p. 90). According to Rollin (1981, as cited by Harold, 1990) experimental psychology was “the field most consistently guilty of mindless activities that results in great suffering.” This debate has caused psychology students to question the use of animals in behavioral research. According to this article there are three reasons why discussing animal rights is crucial to psychology students. First, students should be conscious of political and social concerns associated with psychology that could have an effect on their lives. Second, animal rights issues raise questions related to psychology such as, “can animals think?” or “What are the essential differences between humans and animals?” Third, the use of animals in laboratory courses has received lots of censure (p. 90). To facilitate students to think about these issues, the author has designed a classroom exercise that has students making decisions about whether or not a series of theoretical proposals, pertaining to animal research, should be carried out (p. 91). 3. Methodology Psychology students are divided......

Words: 802 - Pages: 4

How Did the Arts Serve the Soviet State?

...How did the arts serve the Soviet State? The arts had had a different purpose throughout the era of the Soviet State. Nevertheless the Soviet State was wholly under the control of the Soviet System, which Stalin used as an ideology and as a tool to disseminate state polemics. The system was required to suppress the opposition and create social consciousness of an obedient Soviet person. However first it is important to mention that the Soviet State had officially been formed in 1922 and lasted until 1991. And thus the debate concerning the service that the arts had acted upon should start from 1922. The Soviet Art in the early 1920s was relatively pluralistic due to the fact that there were many different schools of thoughts present. There was the avant-garde art, which was considered bourgeois but could not be gotten rid of, due to the fact that the country was still in a state of anarchy. Artists like Salvatore Dali or Pablo Picasso were very popular among soviet artists. (need more info). There was a bigger freedom of expression during the twenties that the artists had not experienced later on. Indeed Anna Akhmatova, a famous Russian author and a poet had said once "To think that the best years of our lives were during the war, when so many people were being killed, when we were starving and my son was doing forced labour.” That patently signifies the extent of control that the artists were under. Moreover her very close friend Boris Pasternak confirmed the...

Words: 1500 - Pages: 6

Discussing the Actions Taken by Workers and Government to Try to Correct Unsafe or Unfair Working Conditions in Factories as United States Industrialized

...The first is the general situation of Industrial Revolution in America, the beginning of factory system, where workers and machinery together in one place to produce goods. Industrial revolution reached America by 1800s and boomed after the civil war (1861-1865). During the revolution, the United States was transformed from an agricultural to industrial society, from hand and home production to machine and factory. Many inventions were created that revolutionized and helped in forming modern America. They include cotton gin, light bulb, telegraph, sugar evaporation system, steam engine, sewing machine… These inventions have influenced the community by giving it a form of faster production and transportation. Besides, transportation expanded. Many new methods of transportation were arisen such as steamboat, canal, especially railroads. The manufacturing of steel, iron, machinery, petroleum fueled economic growth. Urban development occurred during industrial revolution. During the Industrial Revolution, many people left farms to work in factories. Throughout the late 1800s, industrialization fueled the need for more labor. A wave of immigration from Europe and Asia to the United States arose. The whole economy developed dramatically, which attract the huge immigrant from other continents. The supply of labor increases unlimitedly together with demand of exploiting raw material and speed up manufacturing process. Therefore one problem arises are working conditions in......

Words: 2697 - Pages: 11

Tracing the Reasons for Semantic Change

...Running head: TRACING THE NATURE OF SEMANTIC CHANGE Tracing the Nature of Semantic Change Shahrin Akter 1521358655 Department of English North South University Tracing the Nature of Semantic Change Introduction Language never stands still. All living languages are continually changing over the course of time due to social, cultural, environmental, historical and linguistic factors. Semantic change is one of the major phenomenon of language change. Basically, semantic change deals with the change of the original meaning of a word as well as the development of a new word which is reflected in the way the words are being used. This paper mainly puts an insight to the major causes of semantic change as well as trace the traditional classification made by various scholars. According to Varshney, “The main factors responsible for semantic change are vagueness in meaning, loss of motivation, polysemy, ambiguous contexts and the structure of the vocabulary”. (p. 284). Over the passage of time, people use words in a new context. Hence the meanings of the words are changing gradually, often to the point that the new meaning is radically different from the original usage. For instance, the word ‘awful’ originally meant ‘awe-inspiring, filling someone with deep awe’,......

Words: 2548 - Pages: 11


...επινόησε τον παγκόσμιο ιστό το 1989,είχε το όραμα ενός ιστού δεδομένων αυτόματα επεξεργάσιμων από τις εφαρμογές ,βάσει του νοήματος και όχι της μορφής της πληροφορίας Το κέντρο βάρους των περιεχομένων του διαδικτύου μετατοπίζεται συνεχώς από το ελεύθερο κείμενο που είναι πλήρως κατανοητό μόνο από τον άνθρωπο, προς την ημιδομημένη ή/και πλήρως δομημένη πληροφορία η οποία μπορεί να γίνει αυτόματα κατανοητή από διαδικτυακές εφαρμογές ,όπως είναι οι διαδικτυακές υπηρεσίες ή οι ευφυείς πράκτορες. Το Σημασιολογικό Διαδίκτυο αποτελεί πρωτοβουλία της Κοινοπραξίας του Παγκόσμιου Ιστού(W3C) και η σχετική δραστηριότητα (Semantic Web Activity) έχει δημιουργηθεί για να διαδραματίσει έναν ηγετικό ρόλο ,τόσο στο σχεδιασμό προδιαγραφών, όσο και ανοικτή ανάπτυξη της τεχνολογίας μέσω της συνεργασίας. Θα πρέπει να διευκρινιστεί ότι η ακριβής μετάφρασή του αγγλικού όρου Semantic Web είναι Σημασιολογικός Ιστός . όμως η τεχνολογία που αναπτύσσεται και το εύρος των εφαρμογών ,καλύπτουν και άλλους τομείς του διαδικτύου πχ το ηλεκτρονικό ταχυδρομείο. Επίσης, είναι γεγονός πως το διαδίκτυο(internet) γίνεται πλέον αντιληπτό στο χρήστη σχεδόν αποκλειστικά μέσω του παγκοσμίου ιστού. Σαν αποτέλεσμα, οι δύο όροι ιστός και διαδίκτυο χρησιμοποιούνται σχεδόν ταυτόσημα. Για τα παραπάνω, στο εξής θα χρησιμοποιείται ο όρος Σημασιολογικό Διαδίκτυο. 2.Το όραμα του Σημασιολογικού Διαδικτύου Το Σημασιολογικό Διαδίκτυο αποτελεί μια επέκταση του υπάρχοντος διαδικτύου, στην οποία η πληροφορία που......

Words: 10061 - Pages: 41

A State of Art Methods Research on Methods to Assist Customer Requirements Elicitation

...A state of art methods research on methods to assist customer requirements elicitation Fabio Alves Serconek I declare that this submission is entirely my own original work. I declare that, except where fully reference direct quotations have been included, no aspect of this submission has been copied from any other source. I declare that all other works cited in this submission have been appropriately referenced. I understand that any act of Academic Dishonesty such as plagiarism or collusion may result in the non-award of my degree. Signature…………………………………………………………………………………… Date………………………………………………………………………………………….. Table of Contents Abstract 3 1. Introduction 3 2. General process of customer requirements management 3 2.1. Requirement Elicitation 5 3. Kansei mining 5 3.1. Kansei Engineering 5 3.2. Kansei mining method 6 3.3. Case study 7 3.4. Method analysis 8 4. Picture Sorting and ART2 Network 8 4.1. Sorting technique 9 4.2. The ART2 Network 10 4.3. Case study 11 4.4. Method analysis 12 5. Conclusion 13 6. References 14 Figure Index Figure 1 - Customer requirement management process (Jiao & Chen, 2006) 4 Figure 2 - Perceptual design elements for mobile phones (Jiao, Zhang, & Helander, 2006) 7 Figure 3 -Procedure of specified picture sorts for product design (Shieh, Yan, & Chen, 2008) 10 Figure 4 - Customer attributes hierarchy derived from the sorting process (Shieh, Yan, & Chen, 2008) 12 ...

Words: 3711 - Pages: 15