Corporate Psychological Defences: an Oil Spill Case

In: Social Issues

Submitted By kenshinrbt
Words 9258
Pages 38
Corporate Psychological Defences: An Oil Spill Case Author(s): T. Ketola Source: Journal of Business Ethics, Vol. 65, No. 2 (May, 2006), pp. 149-161 Published by: Springer Stable URL: . Accessed: 03/12/2013 07:49
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .

JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact


Springer is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Journal of Business Ethics.

This content downloaded from on Tue, 3 Dec 2013 07:49:34 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

(2006) 65: 149-161 Journal of Business Ethics DOI 10.1007/sl0551-005-4175-4






T. Ketola

An Oil Spill Case

ABSTPJVCT. protect isational morality defences the

Organisational self-esteem even This an oil and moral at the paper refinery

psychological integrity expense analyses and of the its parent of

defences the organ the of


concessions corporation


that is taking


change place.


a more


personality of actions. used by

sacrificing spectrum company

KEY oil

WORDS: spill,


management, concessions,


behaviour, psy

during an oil spill incident. A hypothetical model fences built on

of de

organisational defences,

organisational excuses, organisational

to accusations four responses…...

Similar Documents

Niger Delta Oil Spill

...An Assessment of Oil and Gas Industries in the Niger Delta Thesis Statement Oil and Gas companies operating in Niger Delta are causing damage to the health and safety of environment and the communities of Niger Delta. Introduction Companies participating in Oil and Gas Industry, either upstream, midstream, or downstream, know the pressure from governments and environmental organizations that have been at the center stage environmental issues, while traditional security issues and reliability are even more critical as the industry is driven by strong demand. All the oil companies, especially after the oil spill fiascos that took place in the last 2 decades in Niger Delta, have committed their resources to ensure health and safety of its employees, the people inhabiting the region where company’s operations are taking place, and the protection of environment and other resources such as water. The assessment of all Oil and Gas companies reveals that all the oil and gas companies in Niger Delta are committed to the values, morals, standard and principles that are discussed below in the literature review section (Yusufu et al., 2011, Pp. 34). Discussion Health and Safety: Not to harm people, whether they are employees or contractors of third parties. Accompanying water: Treatment and re-injection of water associated with oil production methods and techniques that are in line with the standards of environmental protection. Drilling Fluids: Management and disposal of...

Words: 2308 - Pages: 10

Oil Spills

...Environmental Implications: When oil is leaked, it adversely alters aquatic environments by physically harming mammals and damaging their habitat. Oil is a compound derived from hydrogen and carbon, however, the process in which the compound is formed, enables it to be toxic to plants and wildlife (Cartage, 2012). The accidental spillage of oil is damaging to subsurface and surface organisms through the physical damage that is done to their habitat. The severity of an oil spill is contingent on two factors; whether it is petroleum or non-petroleum based and the general magnitude of the spillage which is typically measured in barrels or U.S. gallons. Oil is destructive to aquatic ecosystems since it interferes with animal membranes, disrupts the regulation of water controlled by fishes and inhibits metabolic activity (Environment Canada, 2011). Typically, wildlife is affected by oil since it gets sticky over time through weathering. This sticky oil induces hypothermia as oil destroys the waterproofing and insulation of their feathers (Australian Maritime Safety Authority, 2012). The ways in which oil spills damage mammals and birds is threefold; through contamination and destruction of food resources. Animals can be affected by oil through inhalation and ingestion. Vapors inherent in oil will denigrate a mammal’s central nervous system, liver, lungs. Additionally, when the oil is ingested, it may unable birds and mammals to properly digest their food as intestinal tracts......

Words: 1633 - Pages: 7

Bp Oil Spill

...BP Deep-water Horizon Oil Spill Public Relations BP Deep-water Horizon Oil Spill: Executive Summary The Deepwater Horizon oil spill or the BP oil spill was a disaster in the Gulf of Mexico that took place in the Macondo Prospect. Macondo Prospect was a BP operated project, and one of the oil spill disasters that has been considered to be one of the most destructive accidents on marine environment. In fact, it has been considered the most expensive and life threatening accident in the petroleum industry. The disaster was an explosion in a deep-sea oil drilling facility owned by BP Company, in which the resultant explosion caused the sinking of the Deepwater Horizon oilrig, killing 11 people in the incident. The disaster let free a gush of oil from under the seabed, flowing for an estimated three months. The result of the BP oil disaster was indeed catastrophic not just too marine life, but also to all other sectors of the economy that depended either directly or indirectly on marine environment (Alexander, 2010). In what remained to be a disaster, the wellhead had continued to gush oil for up to 87 days before a team finally succeeded in July 2010. By this time, it was estimated that the oil spill had discharged approximately 4.9 million barrels, a quantity estimated to be 780,000 cubic meters. By this time, marine life had been put in jeopardy while a lot others had died, or been seriously affected. Apart from marine and wildlife......

Words: 3040 - Pages: 13

Bp Oil Spill

...BP OIL SPILL Under the Deepwater Horizon, an offshore drilling ring of British Petroleum (BP) caused an oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. The incident occurred on April 20th 2010, where equipment failed and caused the explosion sinking the ring, and causing the death of 11 workers and more than 17 workers injured. The British based energy company also faced other problems at the site of the oil spill. More than 40 million gallons (estimated data) of oil spewed into the Gulf of Mexico. Oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico is a very serious threat for the wildlife as it causes water pollution. The oil spill effected many coastal areas in the US, like the Louisiana, Alabama, Mississippi and Florida. The oil spill disaster strongly damaged wildlife cycle in the Gulf of Mexico, and many species were thrown into extinction. Similarly, thousands of businesses were thrown into extinction. Many people has questioned the ethical decisions and core value system that BP used to cut corners with the accident; namely, the race to maximize profits at all costs. We are all aware that one of the main causes that let to the disaster were the result of bad decisions, in which a less expensive option (whether to run a test or use a particular kind casing pipe, for example) would save lives. There has been “zero dollars spent on research concerning how to handle oil spills for off-shore drilling by BP despite the company's NET profits - above and beyond all salaries, bonuses, or overhead costs- of...

Words: 822 - Pages: 4

Oil Spill

... Gulf Oil Spill Keith Niesen ENV/100 July 22, 2013 Nash Saleh Gulf Oil Spill In 2010 America had a major disasters on its hands the BP oil spill, not only did some people die from this spill, but the oil spill contaminated the Gulf of Mexico. This was a representation of bad technology it also revealed many environmental risks that many people rather ignore. The oil spill also sparked huge outrage as to why this happened and what we must do to prevent another disaster like this. How can we change the way we drill oil and not affect our precious ecosystems and ruin wildlife or are ocean. What is some of the new technology we are using to help with preventing another oil spill from happening? After the oil rig explosion many pollutants were introduced into the air and water. Many of these pollutants were smoke and or hydrocarbon fumes. The water pollutants was the oil and natural gas that was constantly gushing out of the well. The primary pollutants are the smoke and hydrocarbon because they are pollutants that are directly being emitted into the air from a source. There are many concerns with air pollution and scientist have found many chemicals such as alkyl nitrates, methane, hexane and butane compounds the can irritate and burn skin and the eyes and can cause dizziness as well. With all of these samples that have been collected they have not shown levels above government safety regulations (Roosevelt, 2013). Oil pollution we know is dangerous for the environment our...

Words: 873 - Pages: 4

Oil Spill

...American History have we seen the catastrophe that we've seen this year by the BP Oil Spill. The Oil Spill in the Gulf of Mexico is beyond heart breaking. The 1989, Exxon Valdez Oil Spill has been considered the most devastating, human-caused, environmental disaster ever to occur in history, especially towards the Nigerians, since they are still being affected by it. But, even though the Exxon Valdez happened years ago and Nigerians are still in tight situations due to the spill, I believe the BP Oil Spill is just a beginning of a major political conundrum, with lasting consequences similar to what the Nigerians people are experiencing. There are a lot of controversy regarding, who is going to take responsibility for the cleanup for both BP and the Valdez Oil Spill. Some people blame President Obama and some blame Bp for its spill. Blaming the company that is actually in charge of the operation does seem like a logical first step, not to mention, there were many safety warning signs that they ignored to give way to greed. But bear in mind, blaming a president for a disaster caused by a corporation is ridiculous in my opinion. If people are blaming Obama, I think it should be because he didn’t make and veto certain laws and kept an eye on certain factories, if he did, then probably the oil spill would have never happened in the first place. We cannot blame the Spill on Obama completely, but we can blame him for not watching out for......

Words: 847 - Pages: 4

Bp Oil Spill — Corporate Responsibility

...  On April 20th, 2010, the BP oil rig in the Gulf of Mexico exploded. This lead to 11 crew members died and caused large-scale oil pollution. The economic loss of ecological environment in Gulf of Mexico would up to several hundred billion dollars.   As the main person in charge, BP’s CEO, Tony Hayward, did not timely response to this oil spill event. And his inappropriate remarks and performance was even aroused great dissatisfaction among the people and caused a huge loss of profits of BP. “I'm sorry. We're sorry for the massive disruption it's caused their lives. There's no one who wants this over more than I do. I'd like my life back” said by Tony Hayward. And not long after the incident, he was also criticized for having a sunbathe on the beach of Isle of wight in southern England. Under the pressure of public comments, Tony Hayward decided to resign for restoring BP’s reputation. In this case, I think the most important key term is responsibility, both include company’s social responsibility and BP CEO’s responsibility for BP and all relevant people. First of all, I want to mention that this is the most serious oil pollution incident in America. This event not only results in a large area of oil pollution but also caused ecological damage. It caused more than 547 birds died and Animals who live in the Gulf of Mexico will lose their wetland homes. So in this event, Either Hayward or BP, should have considered social responsibility on a daily basis. Here social......

Words: 846 - Pages: 4

'Products That Kill and Corporate Social Responsibility: the Case of Us Defence Firms

...Based on the notion that weapons manufacturers, in addition to other ‘sin industries’ such as gambling, tobacco and alcohol, have unreasonably been excluded from corporate social responsibility (CSR) research, Halpern and Snider (2011) conduct a study on US defence firms’ CSR. In accordance with the overall academic view that industry’s CSR is a result of managers’ CSR orientation (Carroll and Shabana, 2010), they evaluate US managers’ views and find their orientations to be predominantly similar to nondefense counterparties. Therefore, Halpern et al. (2011) suggest that weapons manufacturers ought to be included in the pool of CSR research and practice. Primarily, the article presents the underlying controversy and ideological bias against defence firms and points to the anecdotal arguments presented by researchers and mainly by Byrne (2007) in his publishing ‘Assessing Arms Makers’. Following this discussion, the four-domain model and its background is introduced, together with Aupperle’s (2008) CSR orientation research on chief executives of Forbes Directory. When discussing CSR and defence firms, Halpern et al. present their main argument that CSR should be empirically assessed and consistently with nondefense industries, i.e. using people’s orientations rather than subjective moral assessments. They pose the rhetoric question as to beyond what extent or purpose a product becomes harmful and thus socially irresponsible. What is more, they touch on the idea that......

Words: 1171 - Pages: 5

Bp Oil Spills

...environmental offences typically allow a defence of `due diligence’: if a company has done everything it could to avoid the harm occurring, it can escape blame even if the harm does occur. Why is such a defence a good idea from the ethical point of view? Would BP, on the facts as given in the case scenario, have a defence of `due diligence’ as regards the harm they caused to the environment in Alaska? If so, why? If not, why not? To study or make reasoning on whether BP’s “due diligence” defense can actually exist, the first thing need to consider is the reasonability of effort in which is used to prevent the incident gave rise to the suit. In order to successfully defend that the company did exercise “reasonable efforts”, there are two main branches need to be satisfied: First, that the defendant demonstrate that it “reasonably believed in a mistaken set of facts which, if proved, would render the prohibited act or omission innocent”. (Thomspon Rivesr University) In BP’s case, the pass incident of false alarm could be used by BP to defend itself. However, given the fact that 3 alarm warnings were set off during a relative short period of time, it is hard to defend that the “false alarm” excuse can be used to say that the warning was “a mistaken that render the prohibited act or omission innocent”. Second, the defendant must prove that it took reasonable steps to avoid the particular prohibited event. This second branch is most often used in defence arguments and can be......

Words: 996 - Pages: 4

Oil Spills

...English 1301, 9:05 MW P. Schmidt, HLN Paper# 3 Research Paper October 22, 2014 After the oil spill in Gulf of Mexico in 2010, a research by Douglas. B. Inkley shows that scientists are still assessing the effects of the estimated 170 million gallons of oil that flooded into the Gulf after the explosion of BP's Deepwater Horizon oil rig. The effects of oil spills can have wide ranging impacts that are often portrayed by the media as long lasting environmental disasters. Such perceptions are understandable as they are often fuelled by distressing images of oiled animals and other wildlife. More than 8,000 birds, sea turtles, and marine mammals were found injured or dead in the six months after the spill. In the months following the Gulf oil disaster, wildlife managers, rescue crews, scientists and researchers saw many immediate impacts of the oil impacting wildlife. Though oil is no longer readily visible on the surface, it isn’t gone. Scientists have found significant amounts on the Gulf floor, and the oil that has already washed into wetlands and beaches will likely persist for years. We likely will not see the full extent of impacts for many years, which makes creating and implementing successful restoration plans a serious challenge. Here is a list of some animals that were affected by the oil spill: * Sick Dolphins - As part of the official investigation into impacts of the Deepwater Horizon disaster, a team of scientists did comprehensive physicals on dolphins......

Words: 1286 - Pages: 6

Bp Oil Spill

...Beijing No. 55 High School BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill Investigation Subject: Geography Level: High (HL) Name: Stephanie Chinese: 姜智旻 Homeroom: 10-5 Word count: 1088 Student number: 4192 Supervisor: Craig Hamilton     On 20th of August 2010, the oil drilling rig Deepwater Horizon, operating in the Gulf of Mexico exploded then sunk resulting to 11 deaths. During the 87 days, about 4.9 billion barrels of oil had already spread. An estimation of 42,000 gallon of oil is oozing from underwater. From then 75,000km2 was not allowed for fishing.   Apparently, the blowout preventer device had bad managements and operations, and failed. Investigators said, “The problems with this blowout preventer were worse than we understood.” (Seth, 2014) In addition, investigators have stated that the cause of this explosion was because of the screw ups with cement, drilling mud, fluid pressure, mismanaged tests, and poor decisions. Therefore, this device should be improved so it doesn’t happen again. They have discovered that it has been the device operator’s fault in view of the fact that the blowout preventer hasn’t been tested accurately, there were problems in the wiring and dead batteries.  In order to clean the oil excess, they used powerful chemicals, which they don’t know the effects of on the environment. It was from 1.6km down to the bottom. After this cause, the British Petroleum (BP) went into investigation, negotiating with more than 50 expertise from within BP and industry....

Words: 1281 - Pages: 6

Oils Spills

...Oil Spill Environmental Diaster Thursday, April 29, 2010. The massive oil spill off the gulf coast is an environmental disaster. Since it was an oil rig that blew, the oil is leaking from an underwater well, deep in the ocean. It has been hard to calculate how much oil continues to leak, but today it appears to be leaking at the rate of 5,000 barrels a day, not 1,000 as had been thought, and that the spill could reach the coast by Friday. And they don’t have a way to stop the leaking. This is different that the oil that leaked from a grounded ship over the coral reef in Australia this month. That was terrible due to the damage it did to the endangered (and supposedly protected) Great Barrier Reef. But the ship had a limited amount of oil. Since this is a well that is leaking, it seems as if the oil leak could go on and on until they find a way to cap the well. The oil slick is over 80 miles across. The coasts of Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, and Florida are preparing for the oil to reach the shore line by as early as Friday. The military has been asked to help, and the Coast Guard are trying to burn the oil in the sea before it comes to the shoreline. Whew! The money made by the oil production could be off set by the loss of income by tourism to these coastal areas. The tension that exists between protecting our environment and increasing our energy sources like oil, coal, and nuclear power, seems to be very problematic. I hope they figure out a way to control this leak....

Words: 293 - Pages: 2

Oil Spill

...Oil Spill The disaster that occurred in the Gulf of Mexico on April 20, 2010 was a huge deal to our nation. I'm sure that everyone old enough to understand heard about the oil spill. The spill was very bad, but I believe we got lucky because it could have been even worse than it ended up to be. The oil flowed into the open ocean for over three months, but it was originally thought that it was going to take even longer to stop. A oil spill of that magnitude could severely damage any environment that it was spilt into. The corporation BP took much heat from the government, along with everyone around the country for causing the leak, and not fixing it quick enough. The fact is, once the leak started as it did, it was a very hard problem for them to stop. My paper will cover three elements of this horrible disaster: First, the ecological impact on life in the gulf after the spill, Second, the current economic life of the local communities, and lastly, what is being done to mitigate future consequences. First, obviously the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico left an ecological impact on life in the gulf, and surrounding areas. On July 15, the leak was stopped by capping the gushing wellhead, after it had released about 4.9 million barrels,^ or 205.8 million gallons of crude oil. That is a whole lot of oil being released, so the impact that it had on the environment was a big one. Actually, it was the largest accidental marine oil spill in history. Obviously the......

Words: 1250 - Pages: 5

Bp Oil Spill Case Analysis

...BP Oil Spill | Case Study Analysis | | Disclaimer: To start things off, I would like to mention that the BP Oil Spill is an extremely complicated case and its impact could be felt in every corner of the world. Therefore, my case study is only the tip of the iceberg and should not be used to judge the entire controversy. In addition, all statistics and information have been obtained from other sources. Enjoy! | | By: Haikang Zhu | For: Professor Bill WoofClass: Mgmt 1040 DDate: December 9th, 2010 | | BP (British Petroleum) is a global oil and gas company based in London, England. To date, it is the third largest energy company and the fourth largest company in the world in terms of revenues. Bp has operations in over 80 countries, produces around 3.8 million barrels of oil per day and has approximately 22,400 service stations worldwide. One major controversy that has been following every single oil and gas companies is the sustainability of offshore drillings and their impacts on the environment and the potential problems that might occur. Unfortunately for BP, On April 20th 2010, the dreaded problem occurred. The drilling rig known as the Deepwater Horizon Rig exploded, immediately killing 11 men and injuring 17 others. The incident took place in the Gulf of Mexico and is the worst environment disaster in the history after the Exxon Valdez accident in Alaska. The oil spill stemmed from a sea-floor sea gusher and was the result of the explosion of the......

Words: 2679 - Pages: 11

Oil Spills

...clean up oil spills because these oil spills killed hundreds of organisms that lived in the ocean, and if we have another devastating oil spill we’ll know how to clean it up better and faster, so that way animals that live in the ocean won’t die, like the ones that have in the past. So knowing how to clean up after an oil spill is important because if we didn’t then the animals in the sea would die, when they die there won’t be any sea food and the sea food that was there would be filled with oil, dirt, and slime. Who would want to eat food that has oil dirt and slime on it? In the past few centuries, there has been devastating oil spills, like the Exxon Valdez spill on March 23, 1989. The 987 ft. ship was carrying 53,094,510 gallons (1,264,155 barrels) of North Slope crude oil that was bound for Long Beach, California. The Exxon Valdez grounded at Bligh Reef, in Alaska, rupturing eight of its 11 cargo tanks and spewing approximately around 10.8 million gallons of crude oil into Prince William Sound. Another dangerous oil spill was the BP oil spill, in the Gulf of Mexico. On April 20, 2010 an explosion aboard the Deepwater Horizon killed 11 crew members and set off a massive blaze, fire. The rig sank 2 days later into the Gulf of Mexico, unleashing a gush of oil that continued to leak at an alarming rate. Also, in January 1991, Iraq forces released 240 million gallons of crude oil into the Persian Gulf to spoil an amphibious landing by the U.S. Marines. The resulting oil......

Words: 514 - Pages: 3