City in History

In: English and Literature

Submitted By kaajal
Words 3166
Pages 13
Washington University Law Review
Volume 1962
Issue 3 Symposium: The City in History by Lewis Mumford
January 1962

Some Observations on Lewis Mumford’s “The City in History”
David Riesman

Follow this and additional works at:
Part of the Land Use Planning Commons
Recommended Citation
David Riesman, Some Observations on Lewis Mumford’s “The City in History”, 1962 Wash. U. L. Q. 288 (1962).
Available at:

This Symposium is brought to you for free and open access by the Law School at Washington University Open Scholarship. It has been accepted for inclusion in Washington University Law Review by an authorized administrator of Washington University Open Scholarship. For more information, please contact

For a number of years I have not had any time to undertake book reviews but I feel so keenly the importance and excitement of Mumford's work, and my own personal debt to that work, that I wanted to contribute to this symposium even if I could not begin to do justice to the task. What follows are my only slightly modified notes made on reading selected chapters of the book-notes which I had hoped to have time to sift and revise for a review. I hope I can give some flavor of the book and of its author and invite readers into the corpus of
Mumford's work on their own.
1. Lewis Mumford correctly says in the book that he is a generalist, not a specialist; indeed until recently he has not had (or perhaps wanted to have) a full-time academic position. There are generalists faute de mieux, who cannot make the grade in a specialty; there are other generalists, of whom Mumford is one, who transcend the specialties-indeed whose legacy is often…...

Similar Documents

Small City of Big City

...With the increased standard of living, people pay more attention their quality of living. Some people believe that living in a big city has more advantages than living in the country side while others think differently. For me, I prefer living in a big city. Living in a quiet country side has several advantages. People benefit from clear air, tranquil atmosphere, less traffic and beautiful scene. In addition, people who live in small towns look out each other. This makes them feel secure. Moreover, crime rates are much less than big cities. People are comfortable leaving their doors unlocked. However, living in a metropolitan city has many more advantages. Firstly, many job opportunities are available as there are many companies, banks, offices and international companies. Secondly, there are many facilities and amenities for individuals. Publics amenities will provide services such as sports, arts and computer lessons with very low fee due to government supported programs. In addition, medical facilities and emergency systems are easily assessable when individuals live in big cities. Thirdly, people can have more choices when they buy necessities because there are numerous malls around their neighbourhood. They often buy the same material at a lower price due to bargain sales going on. Fourthly, transportation is extremely important in the modern society, but there are no public transportation systems in small towns, so individuals always use their own......

Words: 346 - Pages: 2

The Windy City

...Historical Visit The Windy City, was all that I knew of Chicago before my visit. As someone who never really traveled far, Chicago was no different as I had never really visited it. So when looking to complete my summer homework, I thought this, the Chicago Historical Society, would be the ideal place to broaden my perspective. The museum itself was a great place to be itself but what really caught my eye were the artifacts, especially those of the Great Chicago Fire and some of the great historical exhibits such as Lincolns Chicago, which detailed the Chicago that Abraham Lincoln grew up in; “one of a dynamic young metropolis on the verge of greatness.” The exhibits ranged from the earliest times of Chicago, building the city itself, until modern-day. Perhaps the most controversial topics within the museum were those of African-American rights, industrial workers, both male and female, and the growing cities criminal problem. The museum offered a large number of exhibits regarding industrial workers, as Chicago itself was an advancing society, the exhibits took you into the lives of the workers who spends up to 12 hours or more within the factories repeating task after task with little to no safety or rest. Due to these unsafe working conditions articles and novels such as “The Jungle”, by Upton Sinclair, were written to expose these issues. Work within the factories was popularized by media due to times of war, as well as being the most is the easily employable job; as......

Words: 594 - Pages: 3

The City in History Summary of Chapters One, Two, Three

...Discussion  1   Zenith  Taskin   211350345   In  the  first  four  chapters  of  his  seminal  book  “The  City  in  History”,  Lewis  Mumford   demonstrates  and  outlines  various  vital  issues  that  intertwine  to  explain  the  beginnings  of  the   city  and  its  various  institutions,  behaviors  and  social  norms  that  exist  within.  The  three  key   issues  that  are  the  most  striking  are  the  reason  for  the  existence  of  cities  aside  from  animal   needs,  the  dominance  of  women  in  Neolithic  culture  and  finally,  the  developing  role  of  the   Paleolithic  hunter.  Although  Mumford  dissects  each  of  these  issues  in  isolation,  he  ultimately   demonstrates  how  they  all  come  together  to  become  part  of  the  earliest  of  cities.     Before  cities  came  into  existence,  Mumford  explains  how  “there  was  the  hamlet  and  the  shrine   and  the  village:  before  the  village,  the  camp,  the  cache,  the  cave  and  the  cairn”  (Lewis  Mumford,   1961,  5).  Mumford  further ......

Words: 1430 - Pages: 6

The City of God

...spectacles of torture. Augustine “City Of God” pg 59- Refute the pagan charges that said that the Christian’s brought the fall of Rome. Pagans said that people should worship old gods in order to achieve material advantages in this world. Augustine attacks the pagans and says that misfortune happens to all. He says that Rome had fallen before even when their gods were worshipped. 2 cities are brought in constant contrast 1. City of God 2. Earthly City Key Ideas: LOVE IS THE CENTER OF LIFE But love has to be correctly ordered- priorities GRACE IS NECESSARY EVEN AFTER CONVERSION Humans are weak and need gods help EVIL HAS NO POSITIVE EXISTANCE Evil is a corruption of the good -Augustine focuses on how the two cities will end in book XIX, and in the process he outlines the nature of the supreme good. He emphasizes the idea that the peace and happiness found in the heavenly city can also be experienced here on earth. The City of God is a completion of the project he began in The Confessions, where he traced the progress of the self toward completion in God. Likewise, human society finds completion in the realm of God. in effect, The City of God is a challenge to human society to choose which city it wishes to be a part of, and Augustine sees his task as clearly marking out the parameters of each choice. Augustine concludes that the purpose of history is to show the unfolding of God’s plan, which involves fostering the City of Heaven and filling it......

Words: 586 - Pages: 3

Shadow Cities

...anything one might desire. However, in Robert Neuwirth's book "Shadow Cities" readers are introduced to multiple people groups, more commonly known as "squatters", who's lifestyles and beliefs challenge what many might consider the good life as generally accepted by members of Western civilization. As Neuwirth takes us from Rocinha, Rio De Janeiro to Istanbul the reader is continuously faced with the same three issues plaguing our world: the fact that the worlds population is steadily increasing at an alarming rate, that everyone must have a place to live and that housing costs and must be lowered in order to provide the amount of houses necessary to sustain our world's growing population (Neuwirth xiii). In this paper I will seek to summarize Neuwirth's book, "Shadow Cities", beginning with a brief history of the squatter community. When comparing past and present examples of squatter communities Neuwirth begins by noting that, "very little has changed since the Middle Ages. The barracks of Rocinha, the mud huts of Kibera, the wooden shanties of Behrampada, or the original Gecekondu houses in Sarigazi are not far removed the dwellings that were common centuries ago in Europe and North America." With very little difference between communities of the past and present it becomes apparent that squatters have existed since the beginning of civilization. Neuwirth argues this point by pointing out that, "the history of cities teaches that squatters have always been around, that......

Words: 1052 - Pages: 5

City of Kelsey

...* Sheldon Rowland * Profile of Kelsey * The city of Kelsey prides itself on history, controlled growth and being aesthetically pleasing. City managers have contracted what they describe as “top builders” to erect commercial and residential properties. Kelsey’s founders witnessed and preserved the rolling hill views, nearby pristine lake, and fields for agriculture. As the population swells to over 600,000, city planners work to preserve the old fashioned, small town feel of Kelsey. People living in Kelsey can appreciate the agriculture history and preservation manifested by the organic gardens throughout the city. Agriculture also serves as a symbol for work ethic and self-sustainability which is a community value. Business thrives throughout the city as residents work in a similar fashion to their city forefathers. Support and services are offered throughout the city, however each unit is budgeted and strictly monitored to avoid deficits and long term debt. City employees, such as policeman and firefighters, recently increased their contributions to their healthcare and retirement benefits to help the city remain financially strong (2013). Each resident is equally responsible for funding the city via a consumption or sales tax. Kelsey has also preserved a portion of the downtown area, and labeled it “historic.” Although population has risen, the city and residents value the small town attractiveness of Kelsey. A benefit of residents working to preserve the...

Words: 457 - Pages: 2


...World War II, the land became valuable to developers who wanted to build homes. To meet this pressure, the City of Dairy Valley was incorporated in 1956. Dairy Valley later became the city of Cerritos. The demand for land became so great that the dairymen sold their dairies and moved their operations to the east in Chino and to Central California.”("The official artesia," ) “The Artesia Water Tower, the familiar inactive water storage tank located on Clarkdale Avenue just south of 183rd Street, has been a familiar site for citizens of Artesia for many years. However, little is known of its active past or when it was actually constructed. In an attempt to declare the Tower a Historical Landmark the City is asking citizens who may have information to share about its past, or have dated pictures of the tower to come forward. The Tower, which can store up to 50,000 gallons of water, was once owned by the Southern California Water Company, and was sold to the City of Artesia as an inactive water storage facility in 1988. The tower was purchased by the City to be used only as a point of historical interest, and to provide a special identity to the community. When the City of Artesia purchased the tower, the then green tower was quickly painted to its current color with the addition of the name Artesia painted on two sides.” ("The official artesia," ) “Every two months the City of Artesia publishes a community newsletter called the  Artesian. In each issue page 4 is reserved......

Words: 796 - Pages: 4


...signature store in Brooklyn, NY. I believe that hydroponic farming can be the key to creating a city with a natural eco-system that produces food for local consumption while conserving energy and water, recycling waste and reducing carbon footprint. The chart on the left side displays the difference between a terminal market and a farmers market in terms of how far food travels. And as can be seen, farmers market sources its food locally, while terminal market uses the conventional supply chain. The difference is almost ten folds. Meaning local food requires 10x less energy, less fossil fuel consumption and less human capital. Source: Leopold Center for Sustainable Agriculture. Data: U.S. Department of Agriculture As all the research points out to, the population increase will majorly happen in large cities. On this basis, the leaders of the world must start to act upon this awaited population change. The way we supply our food is damaging the environment and our future on earth; and it needs to change. It is vital that we start shifting medium to large scale cities into sustainable cities. The opportunities are endless. Cities must start incorporating solar PV, thermal solar and passive solar systems for electricity generation, water heating and HVAC heating respectively. Incorporating urban farms into the food supply chain, educating the under privileged demographics of cities to be employed in these farms will help solve demographical problems as well as help......

Words: 874 - Pages: 4

Is the City of Guatemala a City?

...un resultado reciente, es una asociación de personas libres que dan identidad (a través del tiempo) y funcionamiento colectivo para que sus habitantes vivan, ofertando bienes y servicios. La ciudad se convirtió en un centro de aglomeración humana y dinámica en donde las ideas, el trabajo y el libre mercado, accionan a cada individuo a actuar. Por lo tanto, se hace un especial énfasis en que este espacio es un invento del hombre libre, no una organización impuesta. Donde se entiende como organización impuesta, el gobierno y que la libertad y derecho a la propiedad privada son factores fundamentales para suplir las necesidades de los habitantes. Además, factores importantes como lo menciona Edward Glaeser en su libro “Triumph of the City’’, capital humano sobre las estructuras, interacción humana, innovación, creatividad y educación hacen que una ciudad sea prospera, para que sus habitantes tengan una “buena vida”. Las ciudades en su principio no fueron planificadas. Estas surgieron y evolucionaron por la necesidad del hombre de convivir en sociedad y de hacer uso del conocimiento de los demás sin siquiera saberlo. Es por esto que se puede afirmar que en una ciudad existe un verdadero orden natural; en lucha constante para existir y ser servido: oferta y demanda. Es importante aclarar que el orden espontáneo de una ciudad no se refiera a dejar que la ciudad trabaje por sí sola. Significa que para que la ciudad funcione, la liberta debe existir y que cada......

Words: 2256 - Pages: 10


...Jerran K. McClenton November 2015 AJS/514 City Demographics and Crime Profile Social learning theory considers the formation of an individual’s identity to be a learned response to what a person has been raised around or adapted to. In Memphis, Tennessee, many people within this state are influenced to criminal behavior at a very young age. According to WREG Memphis Channel 3 news, Memphis was only just ranked below Detroit and Oakland, California, but the Chair of the Crime Commission Ben Adams said he isn't sure how accurate the rankings are. Cordarro Vaughn's a lifelong Memphian, and he was anything but surprised when he heard the FBI labeled Memphis the third most dangerous city in the country (Rufener,Katie, 2015). When we talk about events or attitudes to a explanation of beliefs people reside in Memphis, Tennessee would accept for explaining criminal behavior, it points out the general connection of socialization opposed to the individual mindset. The social learning theory believes that an individual’s identity is not the product of the unconscious, but instead is the result of modeling oneself in response to the expectations of others. Behaviors and attitudes develop in response to reinforcement and give hope to the people around them. While social learning theorists acknowledge that childhood experience is important, they also believe that the identity people is formed by the behaviors and attitudes of others. Another factor that contributes to Memphis......

Words: 788 - Pages: 4


...complex ones in cities. However, cities are where the action is. Therefore, new subfield of anthropology emerged, urban anthropology, emphasizing issues of the cities in undeveloped and industrialized countries. This might be due to the reason that anthropology aspires to study universals and wider perspective of human condition. And also cities represent a ‘gateway; to fieldwork which mainly takes place in towns, peasants villages, rural areas etc. Gateway, not just in a physical sense of airports, train & bus stations, but also in sense of communication, expertise (universities, academics etc.), government etc. Although, to interpret issues of cities, the slums, & shanty towns can be done only in terms of forces which lead people to migrate from the countryside. 1. There are a lot of questions studied by both anthropologists and sociologists related to comparative studies of cities and understanding human ways. These phenomena are those of comparison of urban experience in underdeveloped countries. For instance, issues like kinship ties and stresses of urban life and its effects of crowding on aggression and frustration. Thus Anderson argues, on this topic, that due to cultural ways of dealing with crowding the pathological effects on urban Chinese living in Hong Kong are minimized. More importantly, Gideon Sjoberg, created so-called idealized model of the preindustrial cities, in other words, cities of antiquity. One can say that ancient’s city was of......

Words: 832 - Pages: 4


...Student number: 999929323 Course code: GGR 207 Instructor: Dr. Jason Cooke September 29th 2014 Topic: What is a City? There are various ways to define a city either it be from a historical, contemporary, administrative or economic viewpoint. For the purpose of this analysis, a city is defined as a large permanent settlement, which is usually dense and highly populated relative to rural villages and towns, and they are made up of heterogeneous people. As recently as a hundred years ago, only 2 in 10 people lived in cities, but now we have 54% of the world population living in cities or urban areas. The history of cities date back to the time hunter-gatherers roamed the earth. After a few years, this led to semi permanent settlements, and with the invention of irrigation, this led to specialization of other areas and the development of cities as settlements became permanent. As more jobs and opportunities became available in cities, people from the villages moved to the cities, and this accounts for the dense characteristic of most cities. The first cities are thought to have started around 3500BC in lower Mesopotamia after the Neolithic revolution or the agricultural revolution, as agriculture is believed to be a pre requisite for city development. Urbanism can be described as the way cities grow or develop. There are various characteristics of a city; some include population size and density, social stratification, economic production and consumption, diversity......

Words: 555 - Pages: 3


...bronze types which were already invented in East Asia. The mirror image of each letter, rather than entire words or sentences was carved in relief on a small block. Each letter, which are easily movable were put together to form words; lines of type were formed by the blank space left after each word; and lines of type were brought together to make up a page. Letters could be arranged into any format, because of which, a countless variety of texts could be printed by reusing and resetting the type (Kreis, 2011). Gutenberg got the idea of making printing press from existing technologies: textile, papermaking, and wine presses. However, he introduced an idea of molding and casting of movable metal type, which is a remarkable work in the history. He used the idea of presses used for making wine and cheese, and modified the existing ones to make a press for transferring the image from type to the papers. An operator is needed to use the lever to increase and decrease the pressure of the block against the paper to get the image of what is on the type. It was also necessary to develop suitable inks for printing with the new printing press. By that time, there were only water-based inks used for hand lettering and for block printing, which do not stick on metal type. Thus, a viscous oil based ink that sticks on the metal type was required for the new machine. Gutenberg not only designed a movable type printing press, but he also invented suitable kind of oil-based ink for the......

Words: 2525 - Pages: 11

City of Art

...City of Art I have been living in the United States of America over four years. I am an international student. I lived in New Jersey, and Texas before, and been in many cities. .However none of them held me how New York City has held me before. The reason is the art of the buildings. My opinion of what art is, art is a perspective of a person that entertains him when he looks at this art one more time. New York is a great sample if this meaning. Whenever I walk in the city, the time just flies. That is because of there is always some building and architecture new to see in New York. When I look at the view of the Manhattan, I see an artwork that is made by a famous painter. Especially, at nights the lights of the skyscrapers look wonderful to me. There is nothing similar art as New York. If we look at the city as an art, the size of the work is not a compared size of a work. This art is not clay, stone, steel, paint, or technique but building. In New York City, every building has its own vertical, diagonal, horizontal, and planar its own. What makes it art is different characteristic of buildings was gathered together and made a both modern and old city together. For example, you can see an old skyscraper with an old design with a modern building with today’s design next to it. There is not a relationship between the buildings, but as I mentioned before when we look at the view of the Manhattan, everything look relevant to each other. The color of the city is grey, but......

Words: 501 - Pages: 3

City of Kelsey

...University of Phoenix City of Kelsey Team XYZ Ethics 316 May 21, 2012 Week 2 Dr. Had Many Jobs City of Kelsey The following paper will present a profile of the City of Kelsey, a virtual organization established by M. Kelsey in 1932. Specifically, an in-depth profile of the City of Kelsey will describe the citizens, community, and social responsibilities of both Kelsey’s members and Kelsey as a community. The residents of Kelsey have roots grounded in a history of agriculture and self-sufficiency with a median age of 32 years and annual per capita income of $17,725 (City of Kelsey, Profile, 2011). Additionally, the residents of Kelsey perform various types of work, such as technology consulting services to businesses, delivery of materials and equipment, agricultural, and construction work. The City of Kelsey is continuously on the move. The community has several events throughout the year such as an Annual balloon festival, monthly farmer’s market, annual St. Patrick’s Day parade, craft fair, Memorial Day coed softball tournament, golf tournament, and annual 10k marathon. They also have recreational center where family can take their children for a more fun experience. The city also has a prison, which is one of the finest law enforcement establishments in the country. Citizens give back to the community by working at the prison and conserving strong ethical standards. They understand the importance of quality services for the prisoners to...

Words: 619 - Pages: 3