Case Study Analysis Paper 1: a Tale of Two Coaches

In: Business and Management

Submitted By susanaraygoza
Words 545
Pages 3
Case Study Analysis Paper 1: A Tale of Two Coaches Coach Bobby Knight and Coach Mike Krzyzewski are perhaps two of the best effective college basketball instructors in the United Sates. Nonetheless, their management types may perhaps not be beyond diverse. The question asked is, if it is beneficial to be loved or to be feared. Both of these coaches contained within these leadership viewpoints and involved the next significant theories:
• Effective leaders recognize their specific expectations about human character.
• By what method you manage (leadership style) is subjective to who you are (self-awareness) and the requirements of the position (situational awareness). Increasing your self- perception, ability to adapt, and situational awareness your leadership type amplifies your general array of efficiency as a lead. Bobby Knight, otherwise recognized as "The General," is the person in charge to coach the basketball team from Texas Tech University. He is a heated, aggressive individual who leads throughout intimidation and discipline, which several commentators say goes too far with his discipline. Knight was dismissed after a lengthy profession for the Indiana University because he griped an apprentice, and before that, he was recorded holding one of his team members by the collar. Afterwards, the disreputable occurrence in a match happened when Coach Knight threw a foldaway chair crossway the courtyard to object an arbitrator's decision. Mike Krzyzewski, better identified as Coach K, manages the gentlemen's basketball curriculum at Duke University. As an alternative of distress, Krzyzewski depends greatly on encouraging support, approachable and sincere contact, and compassionate encouragement. In favor of Coach K, his leadership trait is in relation to the heart, it is regarding family, and it is concerning realizing the value in individuals and taking…...

Similar Documents

A Tale of Two Coaches

...Case Study Analysis Paper 1: A Tale of Two Coaches John Bentley Grand Canyon University Leadership Styles and Development LDR-600 Armando Sotero February 27, 2013 Case Study Analysis Paper 1: A Tale of Two Coaches It was the best of basketball and it was the best of basketball or was it. The purpose of this paper is to analyze the leadership styles of two successful NCAA basketball coaches: Bobby Knight and Mike Krzyzewski. First, the paper will identify the leadership perspective of each coach. Leadership Perspectives Coach Knight and Coach K were at the center of and embodied the will of their teams. Northouse (2010) described this as a process between the leader and followers…leaders affect followers and vice a versa. Coach night devised a system he expected the team to follow. He said to the players, “Follow our rules, do exactly what I tell you and you will not lose (Snook, Perlow, & Delacey, 2005).” In a similar fashion, Coach K taught discipline too. He invested heavily in drills and skills while focusing on the needs of each player…helping players become a team. Interesting enough they both had one rule to follow…don’t do anything that will harm the team (Snook, Perlow, & Delacey, 2005). Besides a leadership process, each coach used personality to influence team results (Northouse, 2010; “How does“, 2007). Coach Knight’s demanding behavior, meticulous plans and expecting perfection from players is evidence of a conscientiousness......

Words: 2062 - Pages: 9

Case Study Analysis Paper Final

...Case Study Analysis Paper Shawna Macauley Eng/215 May 13, 2013 Diana Penning Case Study Analysis Paper ABC, Inc. recruits, hires, and trains its own employees. Carl Robins, the new campus recruiter failed to organize, follow-up, and reserve a room to train his new recruits. Robins either failed to follow a specific guideline in place for the process of organizing and training new trainees or a specific guideline was not given to him. He assumed certain things and procrastinated, therefore, created a situation of disorder. As a consequence he must make up for lost time and actively correct his incomplete situation. The challenges Robins created by not planning thoroughly were: incomplete files on each new recruit, incomplete orientation manuals for the new trainees, and not securing the training room for orientation. Robins has less than two weeks to correct his mistakes and creatively come up with a solution for not have a room for training. This case involved issues concerning organization and follow through. Robins needed to initiate a detailed plan. To ensure success ABC, Inc. needs a proper training system in place for new recruits as well as a system in place for its new campus recruiter to follow. Robins faces the challenge of making up for lost time and lost resources. This analysis will focus on the issues surrounding lack of planning and organization within ABC, Inc. training and orientation system; as well as the failed action of its new recruiter...

Words: 912 - Pages: 4

Tale of Two Airlines Case

...F . WARREN MCFARLAN Tale of Two Airlines in The Network Age: Or Why The Spirit of King George III Is Alive and Well! As Professor Roger McPherson’s wait to go through the security process a second time dragged on into its third hour on this Spring day in 2002, (all passengers had to be rescreened upon the discovery that one of the airport screening machines was unplugged) he was reminded of another delayed business trip and the role that information technology played in the story. At 5:30pm on February 15, 1995, 200 feet off the ground, Professor Roger McPherson gazed anxiously through the fog as his airplane moved to touch down at Hartsfield Airport in Atlanta, more than 1 hour and 15 minutes late. He had 30 minutes to catch his 6:00pm flight to London, where he would be meeting with the executive leadership of a major British power company to discuss their information strategy. He felt fortunate, however, to be flying this carrier, which had a reputation for outstanding service. He was even more comfortable because he had a full-fare first-class ticket and was a Gold Card member. Professor McPherson was always uneasy about the large premium charged for full, first-class tickets, but knew that in a crunch it often meant the difference between a making a connection and missing one. He well remembered a decade ago flying this airline from Milan to London to connect to a flight to New York. Bad weather then had also reduced his 1-hour-and-30-minute connect time to 10......

Words: 1006 - Pages: 5

Case Study Analysis Paper

...Case Study Analysis Paper Introduction ABC, Inc., hired Mr. Carl Robins as the campus new recruiter. He was responsible for recruiting qualified candidates and processing them through the company’s orientation class. Employed at the company for only six months he recruited fifteen new hires. The company current new hire process and procedures was obsolete. Carl’s coordination in the preparation and execution fell short in the overall set-up of the new employee orientation. ABC, Inc., new hire process and mentoring program failed to match an experienced employee with Mr. Carl Robins during his initial six months on the job. An experience mentored could have effectively provided a smooth transition in preparation of coordinating the new hire orientation for the new employees. Background Mr. Carl Robins recruited and hired fifteen new personnel in early April. The new trainees will work for Monica Carroll’s, the Operations Supervisor. Carl goal was to have the new employees start work in July after the completion of the new employee’s orientation on the 15th of June. Monica, followed-up with Carl on the 15th of May in regards to an up to date status on the scheduled training and the policy booklet for the new hires. Also, the mandatory drug screening tests a requirement before attending the new employee orientation. Carl ensured Monica that everything was on track for the 15th of June scheduled orientation and the new hires are just waiting to attend the class. After...

Words: 887 - Pages: 4

Tale of Two Coaches, Case Study #3

...Case Study Analysis Paper 3 Grand Canyon University: LDR-600 May 7, 2014 Fiedler's Contingency Model In order to understand the performance of a leader, the leader needs to be placed in different situations, which can show their ability to lead. “Effective leadership is contingent on matching a leader’s style to the right setting” (Niorthouse, 2013, p. 123). By the use of the contingency theory, the subordinate’s reaction can affect the way the leader will teach and react. This theory gives better understanding of how the leaders interact with the employees, and if they will be effective in specific situations. “Contingency theory matches the leader and the situation, but does not demand that the leader fit every situation” (Northouse, 2013, p. 127). The styles are divided into task-motivated and relationship-motivated. Coach Knight and coach Krzyzewski (coach K) use in this case study, are proven effective in their leadership styles and approach to their team members, because they both have winning teams. According to Fiedler’s Least Preferred Coworker (LPC) scale, coach Knight will have low score and be identified as a task motivated leader who “will be effective in both very favorable and very unfavorable situations—that is, in situations that are going along very smoothly or situations that are out of control” (Northouse, 2013, p. 125). Coach K will score high on LPC scale which describes him as a leader who is relationship motivated, and who will......

Words: 970 - Pages: 4

Case Study Analysis Paper

...Case Study Analysis_WK5 PSY322/Consumer Psychology and Research June 16, 2013 Case Study Analysis The subject case studies are designed in order to conceptualize the cross-cultural consumer behaviors, their effects on business and company activities while analyzing the case study. The main realm of subject study is the consumer behaviors in global perspectives. The studies are also aimed to create the sense in the students about how to analyze the case study. So to achieve the said objectives the extensive literature review is conducted including the evaluation of consumer behaviors and their decisions regarding purchases while including the lessons learned by the Apple regarding the differences in consumer behavior and purchasing decisions between the Japanese market and the market outside of Japan. The consumer behaviors during the field survey administered under subject study are found dissimilar across the cultures. These dissimilarities in behaviors of the customers across the cultures affect the company’s marketing mix strategies. These effects are discussed in sections created below. Likewise the lessons learned from the Walt Disney Company about consumer behavior and purchasing decisions at Hong Kong Disneyland has also been added as a part of study while explaining various issues that may influence the behaviors of the consumers. Lastly the survey administered identifies the reasons behind the Japanese consumers’ behaviors of hating the iPhone...

Words: 1723 - Pages: 7

Case Study Analysis Paper

...Case Study Analysis Paper Frieda Asep Johnson COMM215 August 11, 2014 Mark Polanzak Case Study Analysis Paper Timeline Scheduling: A New Recruiter’s Placement of New Recruits As a well established textile company, ABC, Inc. has a long standing tradition in assigning job placement staff to surrounding colleges at the end of each semester. It is a means of recruiting the best candidates for employment upon graduation. Also new to our staff, Carl Robins, a Recruiter of six months in the Personnel department, has demonstrated a great capacity for succeeding in his role. Moreover, to safeguard and promote the standards maintaining personnel hiring policies, our organizational workflows have been put in place to systematically or chronologically cluster-link processes with staff, resources, and state of the art technology to complete diverse tasks. After a close examination, indicators strongly suggest discontinuity in the process threatening adverse affects upon expected outcomes. In such an event, repercussions would be exhibited in a dominos effect throughout the company to greater or lesser degree; but the individual(s) responsible to oversee the campaign success, would be held to higher accountability. How vitally important, then, it is to observe with an eye towards turning the well established premise that preparing for complete failure can be traced back to failing to completely prepare—albeit, unintentionally. In his duties, Carl has the unique charge...

Words: 1755 - Pages: 8

Case Study Analysis Paper 1: a Tale of Two Coaches

...Running head: CASE STUDY ANALYSIS PAPER 1: A TALE OF TWO COACHES Case Study Analysis Paper 1: A Tale of Two Coaches December 19, 2012 Bobby Knight is an American college basketball coach. He has the most coaching victories in NCAA men's basketball history. His 1975–76 Indiana University team had a perfect 32–0 record and went on to win the NCAA championship. He was the coach for the U.S. men's basketball team in 1984 and led them to Olympic gold. His temper was legendary and in 2000 he was fired from Indiana. (Bobby Knight Biography, 2012) Duke's Mike Krzyzewski is known as "Coach K”. He is known as “Coach K” to friends and admirers because "Krzyzewski" is hard to say and spell. He has the most notable record in college basketball. He has four national championships and has more wins than any other active men's basketball coach. Only Bobby Knight, who was his mentor from West Point, has more wins. (Zegers, n.d.) They are two of the most successful basketball in history. They share leadership styles, yet these styles are very different. Bobby Knight is an in your face type of coach. He uses fear and leads by using rewards and punishments. He uses tight supervision and control. Coach K believes in empowering his players and sets high goals and maintains standards. He leads with respect. He leads through personal power of being referent. Both coaches are passionate, disciplined, and competent in their jobs as a coach and care a lot for the players both on and......

Words: 580 - Pages: 3

Case Study Analysis Paper

...Nnenna Chimdi COMM 215 Case Study Analysis Paper May 9, 2014 Case Study for Student Analysis To finalize paperwork for the June 15 orientation, missing sections of the trainee files need to be completed on top of mandatory drug tests. Also the computer training room for the orientation was booked for the entire month of June and must be freed so that new trainees can have their orientation. The goal is to have new hires be ready for work by July. Solving this problem will require possible rescheduling, and requiring applicants to refill out the missing portions of their files, on top of taking a drug test before July. Meeting the goal will be crucial because ABC, Inc., on top of the operations supervisor will be counting on having the new hires ready to work by July. ABC, Inc. hired a new campus recruiter back in April and in his first recruitment, he could hire new employees after only working on the job for six months. He set up 15 new hires that were going to work for the operations supervisor. The operations supervisor wanted the new campus recruiter to coordinate with the new hires by setting up a training schedule, orientation, handing out manuals and policy booklets, etc. He was also to have the new hires receive a physical examination, on top of a drug screening. He had the new hire orientation......

Words: 1400 - Pages: 6

Coaches Case Study

...Case Study Analysis Paper 3: A Tale of Two Coaches   1) Through your review of Fiedler's contingency model, would you say that the coaches are matched to their situation? Why or why not? Has this had an impact on their effectiveness? I believe that Coach Knight and Coach K are matched to their situation according to Fiedler’s Contingency Model. Contingency theory suggests that situations can be characterized in terms of three factors: leader–member relations, task structure, and position power (Northouse, 2010). 2) Using Situational Leadership II, provide evidence from the cases that show whether or not there is usage of the leadership styles by the two coaches, and adopt a position on whether or not you think the coaches are effective from this theoretical perspective. In: Business and Management Coach Analysis Case Analysis Paper 3: A Tale of Two Coaches Bonnie Hyatt Grand Canyon University Leadership Style and Development LDR-600 Kelly Jensen, MBA April 30, 2013 Case Analysis Paper 3: A Tale of Two Coaches Fiedler’s contingency theory is a “leader-match theory” (Northhouse, 2013, p. 135).   It attempts to match the style of the leader with the situation and develop a match between the two. Coach Knight and Coach Krzyzewski (Coach K) were both effective in this leadership style because they produced winning teams.   Coach Knight is a task driven leader who sores low on the least preferred co-worker scale (LPC).   His primary focus was accomplishing the......

Words: 1438 - Pages: 6

Case Study Analysis Paper

...Case Study Analysis Paper Melissa Coy COMM/215 Feb 15th, 2015 Beverly Raznoff * The key problems for this case study are as follows: Carl’s paperwork and files for his new hires aren’t complete. Also, the training room has already been scheduled for the whole month of June by another employee. Carl as many issues that need to be remedied such as incomplete employee files, missing paperwork, and the orientation room being double booked. Background Carl has started a new recruitment of trainees for his Operations Supervisor, Monica. In May he was contacted about the paperwork and to see if everything would be scheduled in time for his orientation in June. He assured her that everything would be completed in time. To his dismay a few weeks before his orientation he discovered that that some of the new trainees didn’t have applications or transcripts in their files. The new hires hadn’t been sent to the clinic for their drug tests either. He also found out that another employee, Joe, had scheduled the training room for a computer training seminar for the whole month of June. If Carl wants to get his orientation on schedule and completed he needs to find a way to get his paperwork finished on time and find a place to conduct the training. Alternatives Possible alternatives for Carl’s situation could be: 1. Push the start date for the orientation back to a later date. (Possible constraints: Monica......

Words: 1002 - Pages: 5

Case Study Analysis Paper: Tale of Two Coaches

...Case Study Analysis Paper 1: A Tale of Two Coaches Rhodeanny31 Grand Canyon University: LDR-600-0101 September 23, 2014 Case Study Analysis Paper 1: A Tale of Two Coaches Intelligence, self-confidence, and determination are the leadership perspectives that have exhibited in both Coach Bob Knight and Coach Mike Krzyzewski (known as Coach K.). Coach Knight is known as the winningest coach in NCAA men’s basketball until Duke’s Coach Krzyzewski exceeded his spot. Coach Krzyzewski played under Coach Knight when they were both at West Point and he was a graduate assistant at Indiana University under Coach Knight (Snook, Perlow, & Delacey, 2005). Coach Knight and Coach K. are very successfully college basketball coaches who has different leadership styles of pursuing and producing a competitive goal of winners. Power Bases Relied Upon Coach Knight’s power bases are relied with a tight controlling type categorized by societal detachment between him and the basketball players he coaches. His leadership role consist of discipline and intimidation, sometimes goes too far. Coach Knight’s position of power is high reflected by his regular abuse of verbal and physical punishment. Based on his regular outburst of anger when he was “under stress”, he reverted to less developed ways learning in early developments (Northouse, 2004). Coach Knight emotional capabilities consist of high self-awareness, low self-regulation, high motivation, low empathy, and low social skills...

Words: 919 - Pages: 4

A Tale of Two Coaches

...Running Head: Case Study Analysis Paper 2: A Tale of Two Coaches Case Study Analysis Paper 2: A Tale of Two Coaches Harry A. Gkornean Grand Canyon University: LRD 600-0500: Leadership Styles and Development Dr. Terri Trent September 2, 2015 “Coach K: A Matter of the Heart” & "Coach Knight: A Will to Win” Overview This paper provides a leadership styles and skills analysis of two cases that separately discussed the professional careers of two leaders involved in similar kinds of activities. It presents two coaches – Coach K and Coach Knight - as achievers but distinguishes them in terms of the methodology used. This paper recognizes similar leadership attributes of these two leaders and distinguishes one from another in terms of their leadership style. It identifies Coach K more as a leader than Coach Knight whose attributes were more managerial. Leadership Skills Coach K was an efficient and successful leader who demonstrated excellent leadership skills as he led the Duke Basketball Team to becoming one of the most successful college basketball teams in America’s history (DeLacey, Perlow & Snook, 2005). His success can be attributed to the following leadership skills: competencies, individual attributes, and leadership outcomes, technical, human and conceptual skills. Similarly, Coach Knight was a very successful basketball coach at Indiana University and Texas Tech. According to DeLacey, Perlow & Snook (2005), he earned for himself one of the most......

Words: 633 - Pages: 3

Case Analysis Study Paper

...Case Analysis Study Case Analysis Study This case study is to find out the issues in which Mr. Robins has and to concentrate on a solution. The aim is to share the outcomes of my findings in a manner in which I would tackle the issue and to explain a good solution with identifying the types of problem activities, responses and solution. Among the main factors involved in carrying out his job, includes huge responsibility. It seems that he performed a good job hiring fifteen people with just six months on the job. However with his lack of job experience, he required to have a well-developed, plotted-out plan of action. Obviously, his placement is new; nevertheless it is rapidly found out that he has some important problems in assigning his own duties which are crucial requirements to his job responsibilities. Mr. Robins might have averted a few issues. 1. As a person of his word is important to one’s personality, work ethics as well as moral integrity. 2. Mr. Robins underestimates the strength of his mission and objectives. With having almost three months to arrange, he must have made certain the meeting room for orientation training, was available prior to he planned the date. 3. With certainty, ABC Inc.’s vision and objectives must be the initial steps of the planning process. Mr. Robins must have a task inventory intended to get information regarding his exact job, items of necessary paper work, materials......

Words: 948 - Pages: 4

Analysis of Two Great Coaches

...Analysis of Two Great Coaches Donna M. Rothenberger Grand Canyon University LDR 600 September 2, 2015 Mike Krzyzewski (aka Coach K) and Coach Bobby Knight (aka The General) are the most colorful basketball coaches in American collegiate history. Their similarities are striking. They have shared the same arenas as coach and player at West Point; they are coaching contemporaries; they are competitors, highest winning coaches, and lifelong friends. And, Coach K and Coach Knight have both achieved brilliant success during their college coaching careers. But that’s where their similarities end. Their leadership styles have been the subject of debate around coffee tables, pizza places and beer joints for years. For the curious, there are models of management, though, that can give us yet some more insight into their methods and madness. Robert Katz identified a leadership leaning that made simple the behaviors of leaders based on people and results: Task and Human Skills Approach. The Task Approach favors task and production foremost, while the Human Approach favors relationship and people foremost (Northouse, 2012). Embracing this model, we can understand these coaches a little more by looking at the Katz approach. Coach K was all about the people-relationship skills as priority for......

Words: 978 - Pages: 4